Famous Cookie Creamery

I don’t know about their regular cookies but their gluten free cookies are terrible. They are dry and have a weird taste. Their vanilla ice cream is also not great. It didn’t have much of a taste at all. I was very dissapointed with my order. The best part was the cost. I didn’t feel the $8 ice cream sandwich was too expensive but it was just not good. I’ve had plenty of bad and good GF items (and ice cream) and this ranks pretty high up there amongst some of the worst.

This place is so good!! You can choose what cookies you want for the sandwich and then what flavor of ice cream for the middle. The cookies where delicious and soft, and the ice cream some of the best I’ve had. Amazing!!!

My family and I got the icecream cone, the sherbet, the icecream sandwich, and a dozen count of cookies. The icecream was pretty good according to my family. I tasted some of the pretzel caramel one and it was good. However, the cookies were some of the worst I’ve ever had. Very hard rocks, and I genuinely didn’t like them. I guess they make them fresh, but like these must have been made in the morning or the day before. I just don’t know how it could have turned into a literal rock though. The sugar one is the worst and the snickerdoodle is kind of on the same level. I got a variety of different flavors and the oatmeal raisin one was the only one that I felt was edible without heating it up. Still very crunchy though. I paid a $1 a piece vs $2 like they normally are, but I don’t think it’s fair to say they were made throughout the day when I could tell that wasn’t true. (The last photo is me trying to break the cookie on the counter in order for to eat it)

If you can perfect a cookie sandwich, these guys did. I was really surprised. I savored every bite. Found a new tradition when I come to the beach!

Amazing ice cream flavor and super soft cookies combine to make the most fantastic ice cream sandwich ice every eaten.

This spot is amazing! The cookies are baked fresh, the ice cream is delicious, and the staff is super kind. Don’t miss out on this spot!

Me and my boyfriend went to get some cookie sandwiches there but omg. There were flies all over the cookies literally crawling on them and they were still serving them. Probably 10-15 flies. They also were not wearing gloves and I seen the one girls thumb slip right into the cookie that was already covered in flies and serve it. 🤢

The Blueberry muffin cookie was perfect! I got the Raspberry Truffle as the ice cream. The employees were fast and helpful.

Absolutely one of the best stops for a sweet treat on the OCNJ Boardwalk. The service was exceptional--10/10. The girl working was cheerful and welcoming, which added to the experience. We picked up a peanut butter chocolate chip and a blueberry muffin cookie. The blueberry cookie tasted just like the top of a muffin, complete with a delicious crumble. These treats were the perfect way to end our trip!

Best Ice Cream on the Boardwalk. Bassett's is the gold, no, Platinum standard. Try the cinnamon. Try them all. The cookies are just a bonus, really. Fair Pricing!!! (ssshhhh).... I should not tell you that the Snickerdoodles are other-worldly. And 6 for $10. Whoa! Best bargain, best quality on the boards. Second only to Richman's and Breyer's at Prep's around 10th street. Beware of "homemade" or "our own," and the like in other establishments on the 'walk. Most are made with a commercial pre-mix that is pretty much junk.

Cookies here are pretty good. I have had better, but it's the ice cream here that you REALLY want. Bassets is a Philadelphia classic and has been around since 1861 for a reason. It's so creamy and rich, and the flavors are good too. I'm so glad I can get it on the boardwalk now and don't have to go into the city.

such a great experience here. a great new addition to the ocean city board walk. great if you don't want your typical ice cream every night. got the ice cream sandwich with cinnamon ice cream and snickerdoodle cookies. my sister got one with chocolate chip cookies and coffee ice cream, and my brother got m&m cookies with oreo ice cream. none of us had any complaints!