Jessica Claybrook
Google
2025 update: What was once a beloved spot of mine is no longer enjoyable. They've changed their bread, changed their prices, changed their pizzas, and changed their side offerings and dessert offerings. Spent $40 on two sandwiches and a pizza only to be extremely disappointed in the quality of all three products. Goodbye, old friend.
Old review: I continue going here because I love the sandwiches, and they remind me of the sandwiches made at my Sicilian grandfather's deli. However, my order is messed up 9 times out of 10. I think it would be excusable if they were busier or if there weren't so many people working. I feel like the midtown business has gone down hill since the opening (then closing) of their Poplar location.