Kvatch K.
Yelp
There's a lot to like about Firenze Number Nine: A location that can't be beat, midway between Santa Maria Novella and the Duomo; A friendly and helpful staff; An excellent concierge, and in our case, a large well appointed room, terrific shower, and free mini-bar pre-stocked with everything we could need during our 5 night stay.
But for the price we paid for our room, and it was expensive, I expect more from this hotel. First of all, the hotel's common areas are cramped. Now I wouldn't expect a hotel in central Florence to have enormous amounts of space, but there is no place on the ground floor where one can easily maneuver a bag and the entire lobby area smells constantly of the spa next door (...or maybe the sauna and pool downstairs). You know that watery, chlorine-like odor.
Though we paid for an executive room, and were willing accept that we wouldn't have any sort of view, we didn't expect the number of guests who choose to smoke on the deck area just outside of our room, and smoke they did...continuously...at all hours of the day and night. Moreover, many guests used the chairs placed on the deck by the hotel to dry laundry that they'd probably washed in their room's sink. This gave our little corner of the hotel the atmosphere of a typical Florentine apartment building. Here's a thought people: You're staying in an upscale hotel. Spring for the laundry service.
Finally, although breakfast was very nice, included in our rate, and had a wide variety of fresh fruit, cereals, pastries, and other delicious things, the same couldn't be said of Le Muse, the hotel's restaurant. Although the restaurant was in a "soft open" mode, the menu couldn't have been more dull, and when I order carpaccio, I expect some form of raw meat, not thinly sliced turkey (maybe it was chicken) cold cuts. On top of that, Muse's bartender is incompetent. Would might have been a delicious rosemary-flavored drink turned into a dangerous mess when he choose to use a dried out sprig of rosemary that immediately shed all of it's needles into my drink.
All in all, we had a wonderful time in Florence, and I don't regret our stay at Firenze Number Nine, but this hotel needs to up it's game. They have a lot of competition in the boutique hotel space.