Fit for a Cookie

I was really excited to try Fit for a Cookie and finally had the chance on Sunday night. They weren’t very busy, but there wasn’t a wide selection of cookies available during our visit. They did have a caramel snickerdoodle to sample, which was good. I asked what the difference was between the sample and the other snickerdoodle, as some of the cookie descriptions were missing. I had to ask the cashier for descriptions of some cookies, but it seemed like I was inconveniencing her. However, because of my food allergy, I need to be extra careful when ordering various foods and drinks, so I wanted to confirm. We ended up getting a snickerdoodle and a red velvet cookie. After we ordered, the cashier asked if we wanted a box or a bag, but I wasn’t really sure what the difference was, and she didn’t explain. I saw her taking some fresh cookies out of the oven, and asked for a one. She said she couldn’t give me one because we had a bag instead of a box, but I would have happily switched to a box for a fresh cookie if I understood the difference better. Overall, the customer service was lackluster, and the cookie was just okay in my opinion. I will say the red velvet was better than the snickerdoodle. Maybe it was just an off night, so I’d be willing to give them another shot in the future.

I had the cookie sundae because a molten cookie with BlueBell sounded good. I dove in immediately and the cookie was soft at best, not molten, and the bottom was rock hard. The ice cream was good. The service was great. My score is strictly because the cookie was just edible, solidly in the "just fine" category. For the price, I'll skip the cookie next time.

🅿️ Free Validate Parking 🍨 Must Try their Cookie Sundae, such a perfect dessert for the summer. 🍪 Where every bite is a reward worth craving. From the nostalgic crunch of Oreo Chocolate Chip, to the dreamy swirl of Lovely Red Velvet, the cookies are baked to satisfy your sweet side--without the guilt. Indulge in the cozy charm of Oatmeal White Chocolate Chip, or savor the rich smoothness of Vanilla Bean Chocolate Chip and 🍓 shortcake cookie. Each cookie is a little celebration--crafted with love, packed with flavor, and always fit for a cookie kind of day. Fit for a Cookie is the kind of treat that makes you pause mid-bite just to savor the moment. These cookies strike the perfect balance between crispy edges and a soft, moist center, with a rich brown sugar base that adds a warm, caramelized depth to every bite. You can tell they’re homemade—not just in taste, but in the feeling they leave behind. There’s a cozy, heartfelt quality to them that tastes like someone baked love right into the dough. Whether you’re craving comfort or just a seriously good cookie, Fit for a Cookie delivers in every way.

The cookie i had was the vanilla bean, it's like your typical chocolate chip cookie, it was a warm dough in the middle. It's very decadent so make sure you have water or milk but it is tasty

Update. Fit for a cookie has 10/10 customer service. I contacted them to verify if they deliver or have delivery with uber eats or door dash. They don’t but they made it right for me. I placed the order and because I couldn’t leave work during the time they are open. They delivered 6 fresh baked cookies to me. My order was for 6 cookies. I have shared the with my family and friends. Thank you for the outstanding customer service. They communicated from the time I placed the order until they were delivered. Very professional. Go treat yourself with some of these cookies 🥰❤️😊

Drove 45 minutes to come by the store almost looked like it was closed. There was like 4 to 5 cookies in the glass container. The girl was gone had to wait for her to come back. She heated the cookies up in the oven. And when I asked her for napkins she literally gave me two napkins. When we tried the cookies, they are over the top extremely sweet to the point where it taste like it’s made with artificial sweetener. Explain to me how the chocolate chip Oreo cookie taste like cinnamon maple way too sweet undercooked don’t recommend!

The cookies look amazing but by the time I got my order I didn’t want eat it due to the lack of hand hygiene. I noticed there’s no sink for employees to wash their hands. Therefore they cough in their hands, handle the cash register, return from their breaks and never wash their hands. It was off putting to witness. Please update hand hygiene protocols.

Finally got to try Fit For a Cookie in Midtown Atlanta and wow… this place is a *must* for cookie lovers. 🍪✨ From the second you walk in, the smell alone tells you you’re in for something special. And fun fact: they even make their own butter for the dough! How’s that for dedication to the perfect cookie? Here’s what I tried (and yes, I’d order them all again): • Oreo Chocolate Chip x Vanilla Bean Chocolate Chip – four types of vanilla + four kinds of chocolate = dreamy and rich. • The Lovely Red Velvet – soft Dutch cocoa cookie layered with white chocolate chips and Vanilla Wafers. • Oatmeal White Chocolate Chip – buttery, chewy, and nostalgic in the best way. • Strawberry Shortcake Cookie – a seasonal fave that’s light, fruity, and sweet. • Dulce de Leche Cookie – white chocolate ganache, Oreo crumble, and milk chocolate chips all in one thick, gooey bite. • Cookie Milk – literally tastes like melted cookie magic. • Cookie Sundae – topped with rainbow sprinkles and straight-up fun in a bowl. 🍨 Every cookie is thick, golden on the edges, and soft in the center — baked fresh daily at Politan Row inside Colony Square

This is located in the food plaza at Colony square. The cookies are brought out fresh and there's plenty of seating. The cashier was super kind and also offered samples but I knew what I wanted to do isn't try anything. I ate on the cookie for two days , so good. I love soft center cookies with crunchy outsides so it was perfect . The branding is simple and cute , perfect for a cookie shop.

This is located inside of Politan Row food court. I was here for a meet up with colleagues who were in town for a conference. I wasn't hungry but wanted something sweet, which let me to Fit for a Cookie! The cookies were large and were $6. My friend and I got an Oreo cookies. Other options included s'mores, red velvet, mocha white chocolate chip, oatmeal white chocolate, and vanilla bean chocolate chip. Some of the options were sold out. We had ours warmed up. One major dislike qas that the outside was hard and somewhat overcooked. Yet, the inside was soft. My friend experienced this more as he ate his cookie after he finished his food whereas I ate mine then.

Cookies were phenomenal! The oatmeal white chocolate is the best one, but had a bite of each and they tasted incredible. There something for everyone

Some of the best cookies I've ever had and the owner is a super nice guy. Definitely recommend.

Great service, bomb cookies, a definite must ! I sampled the Oreo cookie and had to have more.