Foggy Nantucket - Foggy's Puck Cafe

I am SO happy Foggy landed their new location at the ice rink after changing locations a few years ago! We love their deep dish pizza so much! It is truly one of a kind, and can’t get nearly anywhere else, especially on island! Such friendly people too. We recommend the Cheese Louise!

I feel like I must be missing something that all these other reviewers are talking about. Maybe under new management? Maybe a bad night? We found the pizza to be nearly inedible. We got a small meatball and small BBQ chicken pizza for take-out at a cost of $48.50. I understand island prices but this pizza had me wondering if we would have been better off heading to S&S frozen section and saving $30. The “dough” did indeed taste frozen and had that cardboard consistency of Red Baron or similar. Sauce was flavorless and cheese had no pull, definitely not freshly shredded. The lady at the counter was very friendly, but it wasn’t enough to overlook the pizza. Maybe the deep dish is better, but I won’t be headed back.

Looking for decent pizza while staying on Nantucket and found a great pizza at Foggy's. From pleasant counter service to excellent pizza. Got a pepperoni and meatball that was delicious and generous toppings. And a deep dish cheese that was very tasty with a nice crunch. Will be our go to in the future.

Eaten here twice everything was amazing exceeded expectations (which mine are very high) ribs and sides were amazing he also recognized me as a customer which I do appreciate. Thank you sir for another yummy meal 10/10 my coworker wanted my food because it smelled so good, run don’t walk. - June

Pizza was delicious, crispy/chewy crust. Green goddess salad dressing that came with the power salad should be bottled and sold separately- it was amazing! And the raspberry donut cheesecake-total Yum. Service was great too, order ready on time and friendly service.

I stopped by looking for the bakery that used to be here. At first I was worried because BBQ and bakery didn't go together in my mind. However, I'm glad Foggy Bakery is there now! Their breakfast bakery stuff is really fantastic. I got a sample selection including a sticky bun, foggy bun, cinnamon bun, chocolate croissant, and a little chocolate cheesecake treat. The sticky bun and Foggy bun were amazingly good. They are probably the best bakery items on the island right now. Really Fantastic. The chocolate croissant and the cinnamon bun were very good. I haven't eaten any of the cheesecake thing yet. I would have included more pictures but my family ate everything but the cheesecake before I could write my review. I didn't try the BBQ food or the breakfast burritos because I was on a bakery morning run for the family however I'll be coming back next year when I'm on island.

This place is amazing! Ordered delivery, waited just over an hour. SO worth it. We ordered the house salad, the porkypine pizza, and donut cheesecake….It’s fresh, it’s original!!! The crust…chefs kiss!! The house bbq sauce was so tasty. Allan was our delivery driver and he was very friendly. Delicious! Please order from here :) thanks!!!

Great spot hidden inside the ice rink. Perfect for simple and affordable food when you don’t want to cook. Pizza is better than most other options on the island 🫣 Support this place!