Rosa J.
Yelp
Folks...you've been comparing Fondue Stube to Geja's or other fondue restaurants, in an apple-to-orange fashion. Thinking about it, is that really fair to Fondue Stube when all your praises to Geja's aren't even pertinent to what Fondue Stube can offer? With my science and criminal justice background, I would like to break it down one (1) category at a time, so there's no more two (2) kinds of fruity comparison incident occurring anymore after my review.
Like the rest of Americans like to do, acronyms will be used: Fondue Stube (SB) and Geja's (GJS). Raise your hand if you have any question at this time (good...no one did).
1) transportation
FS: paid street parking; no valet available. However, it's not difficult in the West Rogers Park neighborhood.
GJS: a mix of paid street and neighborhood parking; valet is available for an additional cost.
2) ambiance
FS: it's meant to be neighborhood fondue place, so the ambiance is in between formal and informal. The music on point, with some soothing classic music playing in the background. The table is MUCH larger than what you will get at Geja's. I have no problem with the decors in the restaurant; there's no tackiness, except the Chicago Bulls banner by men's restroom is a bit odd, but it's not a big deal with me.
GJS: it's meant to be a romantic setting, because you can barely see each other with extreme darkness. The tables between each other are very tight. They have someone professional playing the Spanish guitar. If you want to be a "dark knight" to your lady, then GJS wins in this category.
3) service
FS: Miss Carol's son is always there. The venue is intimate enough to have him to run his "one-man-show," unless it's the weekend. He renders great service.
GJS: their service is commercial. Those servers are definitely savvy and experienced.
P.S. The groupon deal on FS requires a reservation. Do so, and if possible, come early on a weekday because you get to have the entire restaurant to yourself. How awesome!
4) food
FS: it's good, I know the bread isn't the best you will ever find and the beef isn't the supreme quality, but they have some menu items that you can't find at GJS, such as the lox creme cheese fondue. You get to order in a more "free" style. This evening we ordered a la carte. We enjoyed what we had and were comfortably full.
GJS: there's always so much food. You need to get ready to stuff yourself for three (3) hours spending at the restaurant. They also offer groupon, but I don't believe that they let you order in a la carte style. You better stop eating three (3) days before your GJS reservation!
Post-note: yes, GJS does offer supreme-quality food with a large quantity on everything, in comparison to what's offered at FS. I can't deny this fact, but do you ever finish what you have at GJS? I do every time myself, but not everyone else.
Overall, you can have a fantastic experience at FS, if you don't already formulate a perception that "GJS is just better." Yelpers and yelp elites: did the groupon not say that "reservation is required?" I read the fine print and certainly caught this sentence. I made the reservation, came in on time, and came in at a right time. If you didn't do so and were turned away, is your two (2)-star or three (3)-star yelp review really fair to FS?
I'm not writing to advocate for FS; I'm fairly neutral in terms of rating and wasn't expecting FS should be operated like GJS. A small business runs whatever way it wants. What I experienced tonight was a solid four (4)-star quality on all categories I judged on. Yes, having a groupon helped the total bill tremendously; I paid $13 plus the tip.
Now yelpers: can we at least compare the two (2) fondue restaurants in a "red delicious and gala apples" fashion?