Four Marlins Oceanfront Dining

Three of us ate dinner here on a weekday in early November. The restaurant was almost empty so we had our choice of tables and sat outside. This was one of our best dining experiences in Key West. This is elegant oceanfront fine dining. Yes it’s expensive, but for us well worth the ambiance and terrific food and attentive service. For appetizers we had shrimp cocktail (one of the best), grilled focaccia bread (very delicious), and lobster tostadas (yummy). The Four Marlins house salad was fresh and very tasty. The Jumbo Prawns and Grilled Swordfish dinners were incredible. For dessert the Key Lime pie and berry cake hit the spot, as did the espressos and butterscotch martini. Our server Ashley was very accommodating and at no extra cost gave us a couple of extra pieces of the focaccia bread. She also made sure water glasses stayed filled, and brought multiple samples of wine for us to try. We had a wonderful evening and would definitely return the next time we vacation in Key West. Our most expensive dinner ($400 excluding tip) but worth it for what we got. Free valet parking is available so no need to Uber here.

Saw they had a half off happy hour here. So my gorgeous girl friend and I dropped by for early dinner. It runs 4 to 530. Half off a limited number of items and drinks. We got a mish mash of different items. But the truffle fries, smoked swordfish, and croquettes were among my faves. The view from dining outside was very sublime. The staff were courteous and took good care of us. I’d recommend coming and trying them out.

Easily top ten meals in my whole life. Start to finish appetizer, entree and dessert was phenomenal. I will be dreaming of that pork chop for weeks. Ocean view was breathtaking. Service was wonderful, very attentive without being annoying. Will definitely be back!

I want to give this place a rave review because the food was exceptional but the staff dampened our entire experience. My family and I made a reservation to celebrate a special event and spent almost $300 on dinner and drinks. The staff could not have been more rude and dismissive the whole night. For example, we had to beg for water and plates to share a plate we specified would be a shared meal. Any request was made to feel like a burden. The four of us in the party sat on the porch and it started to rain and lightning. The attendants were more concerned with gathering the placemats on empty tables than helping our small dinner party to safety and shelter. Would absolutely not recommend.

Cheesecake Heaven!!! We went for the Cheesecake and it did not disappoint. The generous portion, presentation, taste and texture were all on point. The graham crust was one of the best I’ve had. The cheesecake itself was the perfect blend of density and creaminess. The staff were very friendly even though we were only there for the Cheesecake they treated us very well. Highly recommend if you like more cheesecake than whip cream merengue.

We ate here a few times throughout our stay at the Reach. For the most part the food is really good (what we tried), except for the seafood salad. The shrimp was chewing/tough and the romaine was super hard and stringy. It was probably the worst romaine lettuce of my life, otherwise the salad would have been fine (but not $36 fine). The lobster quesadilla was really 3 lobster tacos, but they were amazing. The mushroom ravioli was delicious. My husband enjoyed his steak and my kids loved their French Toast during brunch. The churros are definitely worth splurging some calories on. Our waitress Thursday night was very kind and kept us informed as they were running very behind and we had to wait an hour for food. Honestly her being so awesome really saved the meal. Being attentive even when the news is bad goes a long way! The hostess Thursday at lunch was not so awesome and if were weren't guests of the resort, we probably wouldn't have been back Thursday evening to even give it a try. The view is beautiful. Overall 4 stars, but the food was good!

The only reason to eat here is for the views. The food is average so not bad but nothing special. The conch fritters were well below average so I wouldn’t come here for that. Their key lime pie was excellent so this is a good spot to have a drink and dessert. The part that ruins is that the service sucks. They add automatic gratuity so they even try to provide any service at all. I only seem my waitress twice, to take my order and then to bring me the bill. Never came around to check on the food or to refill the water.

How can dining by the Oceanside get any better? Well, you can have delicious food and great service from this place. When you go for brunch be sure to try the lobster quesadilla and the smoked salmon tater tots. It may sound weird, but it is not. It’s the best thing you’ve tasted. I promise. The view is spectacular. Thank you so much Tim for your excellent and attentive service.

The view is wonderful, that said if only the view is great but the food is mediocre then you only have the view. At the Four Marlins you can have it all and then some. We were a bit tired from our travel so staying at the Reach made dining here a nice idea. I had not read any reviews going in so my husband and I assumed the food would be okay, but our expectations were not elevated. Well we were pleasantly surprised to find the food excellent along with the service and of course the view! Daniel our server anticipated our every need and checked on us frequently without being bothersome. We never had to ask for anything because his anticipatory skills had already taken care of anything that we would have needed. Starting with the beet salad was a great idea, the citrus dressing was a refreshing touch over crispy greens. The conch chowder was deliciously flavored with conch in every bite. My husband's triple tail fish was fresh and delectable and served with broccolini and potatoes. All the food was nicely seasoned without being overly salty. Everything was top notch. We did not have dessert but we will definitely return for another meal and hopefully have room for the key lime pie!!!

Decided to stop here for a quick lunch since it is the sister hotel to the one we are staying at. The food was good. Husband said the sauce served with the wings was really good! I had a Caesar salad and I thought it was well done. The chocolate mouse was my favorite - I would ask for extra raspberries on it because that added so much to it! The view was Beautiful of the water but it is right by the pool so everyone at the pool or on the beach is in your direct line of sight! So far my service with both Hilton hotels curio collection have been below average. Very slow, very inattentive. They have one server for the entire shift it seems.

Four Marlins is dog friendly, so we made a reservation to have one of our dinners here while we were vacationing in Key West. The restaurant advertises oceanfront dining, but where we sat, faced the courtyard. Oceanfront would have been nice, but the courtyard was lovely, too. As for everything else... The food was very average. It felt like the restaurant was trying to elevate their dishes, but they just weren't very good. And the portions were small. Thankfully, we weren't feeling particularly hungry after a big lunch. The service wasn't great either. Our server was very nice, but he only appeared to take our orders and then appeared again when our food was served. We didn't see him for a long time after that, which made flagging him down very difficult. It was not like there were many diners in the restaurant, which was strange why he didn't check on us more frequently. The only good thing we ate at Four Marlins was the key lime pie.

SWEET KEY LIME PIE Nothing better than key lime pie for breakfast. The place was not busy so we got a nice view against the beach. I would go back again just for the view. Everyone working was friendly. It took a surprisingly long time for our piece of pie to come out. The pie was good but too sweet. All we really tasted was sweetened condensed milk. Add some more lime to it and it would be the best pie in Key West. Overall, if anything, just come here to enjoy the view. I will be in the future to try more.

I have stopped in for coffee to watch the sunrise, and for drinks and key lime pie at sunset. Loved it both times. The key lime pie- amazing. The key lime martini- sour and I would say try something else. Service is friendly and view of ocean truly beautiful at sunrise.

A solid spot for dinner that isn't overly formal or expensive for what you get. Here's what we had. Easy to get a seat but it looks like you should get a reservation to be sure you can get a spot outside: + Oysters (1/2 dozen): Not sure how legit this was with how they didn't have any small spoons and forks to properly eat these and it came with the crackers that normally are more like served with clam chowder. Questionable experience aside, the oysters were pretty good overall although a bit grainy. This is where I took off a star. + Shrimp grits: This was a great dish with well sized pink shrimp that's a specialty of Key West and the grits were well flavored. + 12oz NY Steak Strip: The fried onions were really good and paired nicely with the beef. I also liked the sweetness of the potato and texture of it. Asparagus was also done nicely.

We had an amazing anniversary dinner at Four Marlins! I was looking for a beachfront view, and this restaurant has it! The food we tried: Conch and crab fritters--very tasty! Just a bit chewy. Assorted olives--this was a HUGE portion! They were marinated in this lemon and herb oil which was so good. Grouper--so good! The perfect seafood entree. The cocktails were really good and our server was great! I want to say his name was Adam, but I could be wrong. Definitely recommend this place!

We were staying at nearby sister property, Casa Marina, and came here for dinner as Casa is undergoing renovations and their only open restaurant had too few options. Ambiance is perfection. Beautiful coastal chic decor, light music at an appropriate volume so you can converse softly amd still listen to each other. Stunning oceanviews from all over the outdoor deck. Service was very cordial -- and could be categorized as excellent if it wouldn't have been so slow. I'm afraid they may be short staffed. So come here in super island speed and you won't leave disappointed. We were happy we were able to charge our entire bill to our room at Casa Marina. But boyyyy, was it a lot. Very, very pricy. FOOD: While my husband believes the dinner was still worth it, specially as his NY strip was cooked to perfection (and his potatoes were super delish and beautifully roasted), I feel my seafood pasta had too little seafood (4 jumbo shrimps, but barely any other fish bites) and not bold enough for being a spicy dish. It was still lovely, but at $52, I wouldn't order it again. The conch and lobster fritters were very delicious, but I feel they were also lacking in seafood for the price. While I'm still glad we came, I'd probably chose a different restaurant on our next trip to Key West.

Great ambiance with casual VIP vibes. Restaurant was super spacious. We just ordered a drink (the strawberry moginto) & our drink was yummy and I also loved the pier access and beach access from this spot. Hammocks & cabanas galore. Felt like a swanky backyard beach. Service was professional & friendly.

After checking into the Reach Hilton we decided to book dinner here. Glad we did so we got a table outside looking over the beach. Fabiola our server was a breath of fresh air. She was sweet, attentive and helpful. We started with conch and crab fritters that were lovely. Followed by entrees of NY strip cooked very flavorful, the grouper that was amazing and the fish special of red snapper also amazing! We ended with the key lime pie and croissant bread pudding with raisins, caramel, and vanilla gelato.. awesome!' Everything was amazing!

The ambiance is amazing. There is a nice dock to walk out on to see the sunset. We felt that the drinks were not well made so I would recommend sticking with beer, wine or straight liquor. We only had appetizers which were good. The service was good. Definitely a nice place but I recommend looking at the menu prior to going. It's pricey.

For hotel food this was pretty decent. I recommend the breakfast over other meals. The loaded hash browns were excellent. The lunch sandwiches are what you expect by the pool. The service wether at the bar, pool, or dining room was all excellent. Great views from the outside patio!

I stayed at The Reach and enjoyed the indoor/outdoor dining as well as beach service. Food was fantastic, service at the bar was always prompt and friendly. "Resort" prices are a bit steep but worth it for the convenience of having a really great restaurant steps from your hotel room.

Lobster Ravioli was only ok. Lacked flavorvl thus 3 stars. Fish and chips was large and was great. YELLOW snapper AND chips with great sauce. Seared tuna app. Extra yummy. Spouse even liked it. Service was excellent. Ambiance outside was nice. Would recommend get fish and chips.

Great establishment if you are after fine dining with a waterfront view. I'm told a sandy beach is a rarity in the keys and well you got one here. The food is great and the service is good. We were greeted and promptly seated and had no reasons to complain about our table service. I really was fond of the quality of the food. It felt like the chef really focuses on matching the mains proteins with vegetables and sauces that all seem to find a way to get along as you eat. He presentation was rest and we really enjoyed the key lime pie dessert. We will come back but all in all this is a place that "we can eat"

The best meal I had in Key West! Beautiful location and ambience. You MUST get the mushroom risotto with blackened shrimp. Was incredibly delicious.

Blown Away. I rarely give 5 stars out but this place es muy perfecto! The moment we met with the hostess and asked for a table with the best view and she looked at us and said "I Got You", it was on! The View, first and foremost, is spectacular. If you are looking for the best Oceanside dining, this is it. You got the beach and a pier as your backdrop and it's the picture perfect spot. Get your cameras and your selfie faces ready cuz you are in for a treat! The Food was amazing! The moment I had a spoonful of their lobster Mac and cheese I was in heaven. If you can literally imagine the perfect blend of lobster and Mac and cheese, this restaurant got that figured out! I think I actually closed my eyes while I had that first bite lol. Next up was the calamari. I've had tons of calamari in my days but once again, whatever blend in sauces and spices that they used on this...delicious! And for our main course, hubby and I shared the yellow snapper fish and chips. It was already de-boned for us which made it super easy to eat. Deliciously fried goodness!!! Seemed like that sucker was caught that same day! The main course came with a side of truffle fries - the perfect pairing. And of course for dessert we had a slice of key lime pie. From the crumbly crust to the key lime custard - perfection. The service - flawless. Ashley if you're reading this or if your manager is reading this, you were great! Thank you for making us feel at home in such a lovely establishment. Your food recommendations were on point! And hope you get Christmas off this year because you deserve it! You sealed the deal on this 5 star review!! I am recommending this restaurant to everyone as a Must See Must Do place if you are ever in Key West.

Dinner was excellent... service (Kimberly) was incredible. So kind and welcoming, excellent bar tender. The food was very good. We shared the crab and conch fritters; and ordered shrimp and grits and the yellow tail special for entrees. Calm, casual vibe with excellent service and dinner. Will dine here again. Well done, Hilton.

Very good Food super Location Stuff very quick and friendly every visit is great We love to see the same stuff we like

So I'll start with that the food was good, not great. The ambiance is great, right on the water. They are lacking with staff- seems a little light. They also tend do be confused about where you can sit without reservations.

Absolutely got food poisoning from this place last night. For one, I was not pleased with the service, the quality of the food or really anything. Overpriced and gross. Fake lobster, low quality ingredients all around - pity the fool! Could not even eat more than a few bites as I didn't want to seem rude. We played with my food for 40 min. Waiter then tried to give us the wrong bill. 1 hour after leaving - I developed shaking teeth chattering chills. Vomiting was another level. Was awake all night. Steer clear of this place. I am having a better meal this morning (cheerios from CVS) that's where I felt absolutely necessary to post this review. Don't let this place ruin your trip.

Expensive for what you get. We paid almost $70 for 2 breakfasts and 2 coffees. But it all tasted good and the portions were huge. Our server was excellent. We also had dinner here. Again, expensive for what you get but it all tasted good. Nothing outstanding but good. The key lime pie was the highlight and was definitely one of the better ones we've ever had. Service was less than stellar for a nicer restaurant. Had a margarita that was pretty watered down and not at all worth the money.

We had reservations. We were finally seated and our waitress took our drink order. Thirty minutes later she came back and took our dinner order. Four of us got our food together but we waited for two more dinners to come out. she was not good on checking on our table. I ordered Beet Salad and Conch Chowder. One other at our table ordered that also. My salad had three small beets that were hard as rocks. The conch chowder had two dozen small round potatoes & hardly any chowder. Both orders were like this. Of the six of us, three of us were very dissatisfied. Worst meal i have ever had in Key West! Nice ambiance but will not be back.

I am rating Four Marlins 4.5 stars, but rounding up becuase the only issue with the half-star is prices are very high ($30-$50 per entree, $15-$22 per appetizer), But, its a fancy resort in Key West, so its kind of expected. The food is fantastic. I've been here twice now, and loved my meal both times. They change the menu every 6 months, so my food choices last week was very different than what I got a half year ago. But still all delicious. They also make amazing martinis! My favorite dishes are the ahi tuna, and the snapper. The grouper was also amazing. The swordfish special I wasn't as much of a fan, it didn't taste as fresh probably because it's not a local fish. The short rib appetizer was to die for! But last time I went it was no longer on the menu... but look for something similar next time! The service is wonderful, and the views over the Atlantic Ocean is so pretty. Really perfect setting for a date night or a special occasion. I love it here!

The views were excellent and the service was phenomenal! I ordered the chefs special snapper and wow was it amazing. However, my boyfriends ordered the mushroom risotto and the flavor was nonexistent it tasted like plain grits. Luckily everything else from the drinks to the view was able to make up for his meal.

Hotel restaurant was really good. Great view. Had food from the bar one night and breakfast the next morning. Pretty solid food.

My husband and I stopped by once we arrived from our flight while waiting on our room. Our server was so nice and offered plenty of recommendations for sightseeing on the island. Our food came out quickly and was quite delicious. The only downside was the amount of birds lurking nearby. One even swooped down on our table once we had food on our table

Seated on the patio with live music and an amazing view. Having eaten my way through 7 grouper dinners in the last week. I can say this was the favored. The drinks were delish. The waitstaff did marvelous .... The key lime pie wasn't too bad either. I'd come back here. Just sayin'

Again went off of a TikTok recommendation for dinner and am starting to think that the tiktoker has a bland palate, however food was delicious! First up Mac and lobster cheese needed a bit of salt but delicious. 2nd wife ordered the risotto and WOW! The dish was decadent, several levels of flavor as you continue to chew. 3rd, prime beef tenderloin delicious! The tenderloin was tender that you could brake it apart with a spoon! Lastly, the fish & chips, was delicious and the sweet potatoes fries was great! Desert and this is where I feel that I may upset some readers the "famous key lime pie", needs more lemon in my opinion, needs less condensed milk, not my favorite and I have had better. Nonetheless service was on point, food was hot, and ambiance was good as well!

Hotel restaurant where you pay for the view. Spendy and food and service was not even good. Do not recommend -- there has to be better places to see a sunset. Food: 2 Service: 1 Atmosphere: 4 (patio) Cost to worth it rating: 1 (entrees $40-50 ) Opentableable: yes and can select outdoor Return worthiness: no Highlights: - Lovely view of the beach, water, and sunset from the patio - They had a kids menu Midlights: - Sunset is actually off to the side vs in front where most of the seats are facing - Indoor dining was deserted Lowlights: - Short ribs: not much flavor and more grits than anything. 2 stars - Fish: big cut of tasteless dry fish they made look fancy over mini zuchinis and different sauces. 2 stars - Overall service was abysmal. For being in a reputable large hotel chain and charging outrageous prices, I expected a lot more. - Check in: host staff seemed totally confused and took a while to try to figure out seating of the party ahead of us without a reservation then asked if we were indoors or outdoors when we selected that on our reservation. - Dinner service: not enough wait staff. Waited a long time to order then couldn't find anyone when we wanted wine with our meal. - Dessert snafu: after waiting yet again to order dessert, we selected a key lime pie. Over 5 minutes later, the waiter comes back and says they're out. While waiting for our bill, someone else comes up to us with a slice and we're confused and told her we thought they were out. She said no. Very disappointing experience for our first night and will not be returning.

My spouse and I were staying at the hotel "The Reach (a Hilton property)" where this restaurant is located. It was our first night and the hotel included a $36 a day credit when dining at the restaurant (sounds generous but doesn't go that far considering the prices on the menu). The atmosphere is nice, oceanfront and pool views. I ordered a caesar salad, and my husband had grilled fish in a coconut curry sauce. Overall the food was decent, but definitely hotel prices. My salad was drenched in parmesan shavings, which I didn't necessarily mind, but it was a bit unconventional. My biggest critique was the service, the waiter was a bit inattentive and seemed confused most of the time about what we were saying. English is not my husband's first language so I found his responses to my husband's accent a bit rude. I would probably have given the restaurant a "very good" rating if the service has been better. To summarize, it's a fine place to grab a bite to eat if you're staying in the hotel, if you're not staying in the hotel probably not worth the trek over just to eat here.

This place is awful. Worst cheap food. I think I'm so mad because it's grossly overpriced. $50-64 for an entree?!? We stayed at the resort so we got stuck with them.

Fabulous ocean view while you dine. This restaurant serves as the main food spot for the Hilton Reach hotel. We come here for breakfast while staying at the Reach or the Waldorf Astoria Casa Marina, as you can use your resort credit in the restaurant. Since this is part of the hotel, you pay hotel prices for the food. Sit outside on the patio enjoying the sounds of the waves crashing. I order the coastal sunrise, which is 2 eggs, bacon or chicken sausage, hash browns and toast. Good overall meal. My wife enjoys the breakfast Turkey BLT.

We walked over here from our Airbnb on our first outing when we got to Key West. We were hungry and thirsty for some apps and margs! This place is great! What an amazing view of the water and great food we had! Highly recommend for the views. We also went the other restaurant down the way and this one had better views and better ambiance!

We were excited to eat at Four Marlins last night as we were staying at the sister property. Arrived and were seated outside and ordered our food and drinks. As the appetizers were delivered, the termites started flying all over us. The waitress said "oh they are just termites, we have been having a problem with them" as if it wasn't a big deal. We asked to move inside which they did but the termites were inside also flying all over us (as several other diners did the same thing). We asked for our bill before our main dishes came out so we could leave ($80 for 2 drinks and 2 appetizers). The whole experience was totally gross and disgusting to have termites flying literally all around and on us no matter if we were outside or inside. They need to get this under control as I would never recommend this place even though the appetizers were very tasty but unfortunately our entire evening was ruined and didn't get to eat our main courses as there was no way anyone would or should eat with tons of termites landing on them.

Good food and ambience if you are in for a special night. Be sure to dress up. Our server was really good even though we went there on Christmas Day. Very cheerful person even though she was probably working on a day that she would have loved a day off. We loved the experience. We had a vegetarian chili and kids cheeseburger. Will recommend the chili for any vegetarians out there.

Upscale restaurant that had a water view. You can even plan and reserve a table right on the beach what's better than a romantic dinner in the sand. They have. A nice menu and full bar to choose from. I had the cucumber cocktail and I was surprised by how delicious it was. Hubby had a dirty gin martini that he really enjoyed. We dinner here twice during our stay and had two great meals.

Ask for a table with an ocean view, get a tasty cocktail, and then go straight for the Key Lime Pie.

Order the Lobster Mac and Cheese! It was our tables favorite appetizer. But each plate we ordered was delicious. We sat outside and the beach view is beautiful. The staff were kind and attentive. I would definitely come back and dine here again!

Outstanding food and ambiance. Highly recommend!! Shrimp and grits were delish, as well as the grouper. Very ample portions.

Stopped by to have dinner with my boyfriend, the view was incredible! Very nice and clean place, it is located in a hotel so you need to go through the lobby before seeing the restaurant. Everyone was ver nice and attentive. We ordered the lobster Mac and cheese and the conch fritters, they we delicious and tasted so fresh ! My favorite of it all was the key lime pie! I have to say it's the best key lime pie I've tried in the keys. Will definitely come here again !

Wonderful outdoor seating so make your reservations early. We enjoyed the share menu and save room for dessert, some nice choices.

The ambiance of this restaurant was super nice if you're looking for a Keys type of environment. The restaurant is decorated coastal and has so many photo opportunities. The staff was very nice and attentive. The only downside to this place was the amount of food options. I went to the restaurant because I really wanted their lobster Mac & cheese and they informed me that they had removed it from the menu. I ordered the Turkey sandwich and it was fresh and my boyfriend ordered the short rib burger and said it was pretty good. I would definitely come back if more seafood items are added to the menu.

Recommended to eat here by a tik-tokker I follow- Shay Spence. Thank goodness, because this place is on the 'far side' of the island, kinda hidden, and I would of never found this place for him. Highly recommend the lobster mac and cheese- Shay recommended, and I concur. I have no gallbladder, and lactose intolerant- this was worth the drama, let me tell you. The cheese sauce was infused with lobsta flavor, giant hunks of lobster, and crispy delightful topping. I was raised that ladies always leave a little on the plate- not this time, chica. I didn't exactly lick the bowl, their might have been mild moaning, but it was all lady like, I assure you. Then, there was the key lime pie. I should have stopped at the mac and cheese. No gallbladder. The lactose thing. But I heard this was THE BEST KEY LIME PIE IN ALL OF KEY WEST and I specifically came here for the pie and mac. So, in I dove with my fork by my side, like a knight going into battle with a sword. Incredible. No words. Perfect. Don't bother having key lime anything, anywhere else. It just doesn't get any better than this. Chef's kiss.

Staying at the Reach for a week, we had various meals here and I can say that most were barely satisfactory. Breakfast/Brunch: There is a good selection, I can recommend the egg sandwich and the hash browns were quite good too. However, the oatmeal was disappointing and the classic egg breakfast (which they call Coastal Sunrise) was nothing special. Lunch: this was the better meal of the day based on our experience - if you ignore the sad portion size. If I think about our favorites: Fish tacos were really good, so were the crab cakes but the portions are like an appetizer (even though they charge $27 for 3 mini fish tacos). As sides - fries were very crispy and tasty but the Caesar Salad was lacking flavor. Dinner: Worst menu / execution among the different meals we had there. I dont even know where to start. My partner thought the oysters tasted very off (and he knows his oysters!), the patatas bravas was inedible and in my opinion an insult to the real thing, the mahi fritters were soaked in oil-fried wrong, the blackened grouper - passable but not properly blackened, the chicken - very average. Key lime pie- not bad but also very average (and high in sugar) based on the others in the island. Drinks: they have a good selection for wine and beer, the cocktails were average and my fav would be the watermelon margarita. Prices: we both thought the prices were waaay to high for the offer. I understand that they are a part of Hilton which increases the prices, but we stayed in many Hiltons over the years and the restaurant/bars they have usually offer a more high-end experience, justifying the price. so in this case - I was quite disappointed.

Service was excellent. Food was way less than expected. We ordered fish tacos and turkey club. The turkey club came and they brought something we did not order instead of fish tacos. It was going to take another 10-15 minutes so we shared the turkey club and let waitress know. After 10 minutes, the fish tacos came and we told them we already canceled it. They were confused. Expected much more from a restaurant at a resort hotel.

We absolutely loved this place. Our waiter (Daniel) was so kind and guided our selections. The view was stunning, directly on the water. We will definitely be back, so far our favorite spot in town.

Heard about this place through Shay Spence's TikTok account - key lime pie is my favorite dessert and he said Four Marlin's had the best in Key West so I had to try it out! We got there right when lunch started and were seated outside by the water so we had beautiful views while we dined. We started with the calamari (good) and the conch & crab fritters (excellent), and I had the fish tacos which were fresh and delicious. Now I've had quite a few different key lime pies while in Key West - some were too tart, some had stale or soggy graham cracker crust, some were decent but not spectacular. This pie though....was the best key lime pie I have ever had in my entire life. It was the perfect balance of tart, sweet, creamy, buttery, and rich. I wish I lived closer so I could eat this all the time but it was such a spectacular treat. The menu prices are a little high but the food is great and it's worth it completely for the pie alone!

Great location. Amazing food and drinks. The seafood and shellfish were very fresh and you could tell that they paid attendance to the details (e.g. buttered and toasted bread roll for the lobster roll). I asked for a site of the cilantro aioli for my fries which they accommodated - YUMMY!

This place checked off the boxes: great view, great food, great service. Both meals were big portions and we left full and happy. Great way to start the day with ocean views, a bloody mary in hand and some good breakfast.