Jamarcus T.
Yelp
I've known of the Frosty Caboose for years. Driving by this place several times, and never stopping in due to crowds, it wasn't until fellow yelper Tammi D and I were fresh from a park walk at the nearby Dresden park, that we stopped here for some ice cream when crowds were low.
I ordered the following:
1 Cup of ice cream ($3.25)
For no extra charge, you can split your cup with two flavors. Of the two flavors, I got their ACHHHH, Like BUTTAH pecan, and Sea turtle madness.
My favorite of the two flavors definitely was the Butter pecan. Creamy, but a bit too sweet. They did manage to keep a bit of the crunch on the pecans when you bit into it though, so not bad!
The Sea turtle madness is salted caramel, and as the frosty caboose staff says, no turtles were harmed in making this ice cream. While this wasn't bad ice cream, it fell short to me in terms of flavor, and I wasn't wow'd at all.
There are a couple of lots for the caboose, although the paved lot we were on had heavily faded parking lines, making it a bit hard to see where/how to park.
The Caboose itself is a kid magnet, and that's definitely one of the great draws of this place. Parents bring their kids and kids climb all over the caboose. Who cold resist a train and ice cream on a sunny day??
While I only tried two flavors, the frosty caboose offers 36 dedicated flavors year round, and also offers a handful of season flavors. Maybe if/when I go back i'll pick different flavors that appeal to me a little bit better than what I tried. For now though, i've tried a lot of really good ice cream and i've had much better.
This ultimately is what I think is the Caboose's biggest issue for me. There's a lot of ice cream competition in Georgia and the general area of chamblee/buford highwy, that do just as good or better. For this reason, i'll definitely be back.....it just may be a while.