Jessica H.
Yelp
Looking for somewhere new - and a little bit different - for dinner recently, it occured to me that the new San Carlo Fumo was only around the corner. After a look on the (very nicely designed) website, we thought it looked like a great, slimmed down, menu compared to the places we usually frequent.
We were warmly welcomed by front of house and given the choice of basically all the tables in the room; aside from a few families and couples, it was empty - after all, it was a Sunday! When the menu was presented to us, I was surprised and, if I'm honest, a little bit disappointed to find that it was a large and sprawling menu. Bye bye the previously admired, assumed to be carefully selected menu, and hello to a vast selection of Italian meals.
Oh, and hello to the strange 'display' of a lemon and tomato on the table.
Advised that it was almost like Italian tapas, we ended up with a table overflowing with food. Ravioli with spinach & cream cheese and a sweet tomato sauce, fried mozzarella, a special of gnocchi with parmesan 'fondue', ham & cheese calzone, pork belly, and courgette fries.
I won't bore with the intimate details of each plate, but I will say that the gnocchi and calzone were the least exciting dishes, the gnocchi needing a healthy addition of pepper to get any real flavour and the calzone (although being tasty enough) needing more time in the oven for some crisp.
The ravioli was a stand out favourite, and the courgette fries were a delicious 'alternative' side, especially as there was no need for any more carbs on our table at this point.
As if we hadn't eaten enough, we decided to indulge in the cicchetti of desserts, which is basically a massive board with a miniature selection of their puds. It was impressive enough, but felt fairly old school, with a huge covering of chocolate powder/icing sugar. We managed to polish off the majority, but I can actually imagine this being best sat at the bar after a bottle of wine, as opposed to after a huge meal.
I'd give it another go as Manchester always needs more Italian options, but I can't help but feel the look of the website is no where reflected in the actual restaurant. At least at the moment.