Gallagher's Steakhouse

Although I had a reservation, there was still a bit of a wait for a table. I did not order an appetizer, but it still took about an hour to receive my steak after sitting down. My reservation was at 7:15 and I barely made a 9:30 show at Mandalay Bay. I am not bothered by the wait, but rather just sharing. The wait aside, the drinks were fantastic. My 8oz filet mignon was cooked perfectly. The service was fantastic - the server and others (presumably managers) routinely checking in. I never went without a full cocktail at my table! I wanted to do a dessert, but there just wasn’t time. Maybe I’ll stop in for that before I leave.

Scott & his assistant server on 8/18/24 gave top notch service!! We came as a party of 5 to celebrate my dads birthday. It was a last minute impulsive decision however it was the BEST DECISION, BEST SERVICE, BEST DISH we have had in Vegas and we come here at least twice a year. Such a wonderful hidden gem. We had salmon, chicken and steak at our table 10 out of 10. Again, my waiter Scott was everything amazing and both my family and I said this place is a MUST with Scott being our fine waiter every time we are in town! We love it here… oh and atmosphere is everything you forget you’re in the rush lime light of Vegas

Great restaurant in New York, New York. There's a great vibe inside, with waiting staff very attentive & polite. The food is exceptional, although the prices do reflect that. There is a number of steaks or seafood to choose from or have a 3 course meal from the preselected menu.

ADAM gave great service. On the website, it says business casual and men must have long sleeves shirts and no tank tops and gym shoes. The guest had all of the above so I came overdressed. Other than that everything was Great!

I had been eagerly anticipating my visit to this New York classic all week. Let’s start with the service—impeccable, thanks to barman Joe. He makes a mean Old Fashioned that should not be missed while you’re waiting for your table. I dove right into the steak, ordering the bone-in ribeye USDA Prime—cowboy-sized for the big boys—with an add-on of Oscar-style sauce with crab lumps. The steak was delectable all around, cooked to a perfect medium-rare. However, my only gripe is that the char was not as present as it is at some elite steakhouses like Gibson’s in Chicago. Minimal char on a steak at this price point is a letdown, costing it one star in my book. That said, the steak was well-flavored with a nice smoky aftertaste. Definitely drop by this steakhouse the next time you’re at New York-New York.

Been here a couple times and not disappointed. Steak is clearly on point. Wife prefers shrimp and apps, which are plump and plentiful, as the photo shows. Both server and bartender were top-notch professionals. Was not expecting out of a New York New York restaurant. My friend suggested to me, and now I'm suggesting to you all: Eat here.

What a wonderful dinner! Kris provided exceptional service. It was so nice to meet the chef. Our steaks were perfectly cooked. We will definitely be back!

What a hidden gem! I love how I was transported away from the casino noise into this tranquil, classy, delicious atmosphere. The service was quick- I would even say too quick. It made me feel like a number instead of a revered customer. That aspect- I didn’t like. The food was plentiful. There were a couple of choices in the bread basket which was nice. I enjoyed the creativity of the cranberry bread. While it didn’t suit my craving for savory bread, it was delicious. I loved the sourdough though. The steak tartare was very good. It had some grilled bread and a cute quail egg on top. The Caesar salad was good but nothing to write home about. It was dressed on the heavy side and needed some acidity but it was good. The ribeye was perfectly cooked and really affordable! Plenty of food for 2 people. And the piece de resistance was the Brandy peppercorn sauce. Wow, it brought the steak to a level we couldn’t imagine. My mouth is watering just writing about it. We finished the meal with sticky toffee pudding. Freaking amazing paired with hot green tea. I cannot wait to come back here.