Randy B.
Yelp
Well, Zachary's across the street was booming and had a wait, so what the heck, try a new place to Yelp about...Gay Nineties Pizza...batter up!
Inside the front room and check-in area, a cute dive bar with a handful of tables. I was dining with the gf and the pooch, so we wanted to sit outside. They weren't very friendly to dogs, and no accommodation for a service animal, neither. We didn't press it, and decided to sit at 1 of the six tables offered to us at the curbside.
The menu looked good! Besides the usual things, they have a hell of a lot of toppings including rare to find for pizza: Artichoke Hearts, Eggplant, Broccoli, Zucchini, and/or Summer Squash. Nice!
We chose the medium Veggie Special w/Bell Peppers, Onions, Olives, Mushrooms, Artichoke Hearts, & Fresh Tomatoes, and added Pepperoni to it. In about 20 mins, it arrived. The crust was quite thick, thicker than I like. I didn't see it on the menu, but they also have thin, and even "extra thick". Wow. [$32.55, 2.0 stars]
Well, it disappointed. The veggies were fresh, but had very little sauce and very little cheese. It was so bland. We asked one of the other waiters who was nearby, and he brought us out a cup of extra sauce. But even that was bland. No flavor at all. Do they use any seasoning in it such as Oregano, salt, and pepper?
Conner, the Manager, came out to introduce himself. Very nice guy! He explained since 1959, the sauce is the original recipe...unseasoned! He also confirmed they use for little sauce, and you can always order a pizza with heavy sauce.
Well Conner, thanks for confirming. You're bland-tasting pizza is not for me. I also don't like the crust. Homemade or not, it's not delicious...and I can't imagine ordering THICK crust for a whole lot more of it. It's also bland, no salt, not buttery...it's just there. A big NO.