Gerritsen Bagels Inc

Bagel shop · Gerritsen Beach

Gerritsen Bagels Inc

Bagel shop · Gerritsen Beach

2

2712 Gerritsen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229

Photos

Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by Carina Finn
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by @TheInfatuation
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null
Gerritsen Bagels Inc by null

Highlights

Flavorful, sizable bagels; rainbow & pumpernickel specialties  

Featured in The Infatuation
Placeholder
Placeholder

2712 Gerritsen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229 Get directions

@gerritsenbagels

$10–20

Information

Static Map

2712 Gerritsen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229 Get directions

+1 718 646 0200
@gerritsenbagels

$10–20

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay

Last updated

Aug 8, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@infatuation

The Best Restaurants In Sheepshead Bay

"Technically located across the border in Gerritsen Beach, this local-favorite bagel spot might just have the most delicious rainbow bagel in Brooklyn. It’s fluffier and more flavorful than most of its kind, and on the weekend you can get it with colorful funfetti cream cheese. The breakfast sandwiches here are on-point too, and the pumpernickel everything bagel is dense and chewy, like a loaf of great rye bread. Walk down to the end of Gerritsen Avenue and eat your bagel out on The Point, a secluded beach overlooking Gerritsen Creek. Here, you can experience the strange juxtaposition of standing between the edges of the water and the salt marsh, the Belt Parkway humming in the distance. It’s a bit bizarre, like something out of a sci-fi movie, so you’ll need that bagel to keep you grounded." - carina finn koeppicus

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/guides/best-restaurants-sheepshead-bay
View Postcard for Gerritsen Bagels Inc
@infatuation

Gerritsen Bagels - Review - Sheepshead Bay - New York - The Infatuation

"Technically across the Sheepshead Bay border in Gerritsen Beach, this local-favorite bagel spot might just have the most delicious rainbow bagel in Brooklyn. It’s fluffier and more flavorful than most of its kind, and on the weekend you can get it with colorful funfetti cream cheese. The breakfast sandwiches here are on-point too, and the pumpernickel everything bagel is dense and chewy, like a loaf of great rye bread. Walk down to the end of Gerritsen Avenue and eat your bagel out on The Point, a secluded beach overlooking Gerritsen Creek. Here, you can experience the strange juxtaposition of standing between the edges of the water and the salt marsh, the Belt Parkway humming in the distance. It’s a bizarre experience, like something out of a sci-fi movie, so you’ll need that bagel to keep you grounded. photo credit: Carina Finn" - Max Bonem

https://www.theinfatuation.com/new-york/reviews/gerritsen-bagels
View Postcard for Gerritsen Bagels Inc

John Mastroianni

Google
BEST BAGEL EVER!!!! Not as good as it used to be but still the best I’ve had from anywhere and I stand by that. I’ve been going here for years and I honestly haven’t had anything better. Their bacon egg and cheese needs a little work but the bagel makes up for it. I got a BLT on an everything bagel today and it was awesome. Fresh ingredients, crispy bacon, and well packed with ingredients. Still amazing prices as well, can’t find a bacon, egg and cheese anywhere for less than $6 anymore. Some new employees aren’t the best but they’ll learn from the veteran employees. I come here every time I come to Brooklyn.

Muriel Rand

Google
Best bagel shop anywhere!! The bagels are huge, very flavorful, with a great texture. I especially love the whole wheat everything. They also have pumpernickel everything and egg everything. We go out of way to stop here. Service is great and the little shop is just the way bagel shops should be.

Monica “Monica Rubin Ghee” Rubin Ghee

Google
The best bagels 🥯 are right here made the old fashioned way they close early so get some in the morning!!! Fantastic sandwiches excellent coffee ☕ wonderful staff

Samantha Diz

Google
Horror movie of a morning. Came in and ordered an egg and cheese on a roll with ketchup and Mayo. Then proceeded to ask for Turkey sausage, the guy attending me said they had Turkey bacon so I opted for the bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel with just butter (two different sandwiches). As they are making it I noticed that they put ketchup and Mayo on the bagel instead of the roll. I notified him and it was corrected. I paid and left. When I got home the egg and cheese was missing from the bag so I came back . He immediately recognized me and gave me the bag with the sandwich. I went all the way home again, just to realize he put bacon in the sandwich. So I went back again and told him I ordered no bacon. He fixed the order didn’t say a word to me. No apology for now having to come 3 times. The lady gives me The new bag and I leave. Just to Come right back a 4th time because he put BACON IN IT AGAIN. This time I went in and told him he made it wrong again. I told him I wanted the money back and his attitude was disgusting he practically threw the money at me and proceeded to blame me for ordering 2 BEC sandwiches. I told him that was impossible because I ordered both sandwiches separately with different instructions as stated in the beginning. I told him he messed up or didn’t understand me correctly . And he insisted I ordered wrong and he was right. I demand he gets fired, there was no apology or compensation. Wasted my time, money, and Gas. I also ordered a muffin with butter . He threw a huge slap of cold butter and left it like that . I got 2 chocolate chip cookies and they tasted horrible. Management needs to changes because this is UNACCEPTABLE .

Floor cleaning services

Google
I highly recommend this place to anyone… their bagels 🥯 are the best and they’re super fresh. I hope one day they can put out door table to sit down and have your breakfast or lunch that would be great. The people that work at that place are very friendly and nice 👍🏻

Eddie Pejcinovic

Google
VERY GOOD BAGELS , BUT IM DONE GOING THERE ONE WORKER FEMALE LADY IS NOT SERVING INSTEAD SWEEPING CLEANING ,WHENA COSTUMER WALKS IN STOP WHAT U DOING OR SAY ILL BE WITH U ONE MIN. ME AND SON LEFT AND WILL NOT RETURN.

Jonathan Kojoher

Google
I always get my bagels here. Been coming here for years. Delicious bagels

Debbi Mannino

Google
Not much atmosphere here but the bagels ( which you can see being made) are spot on. Great stop to grab a bagel sandwich or a dozen