Gerritsen Bagels Inc

Bagel shop · Gerritsen Beach

Gerritsen Bagels Inc

Bagel shop · Gerritsen Beach

2712 Gerritsen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229

Highlights

Tucked away in Gerritsen Beach, this local bagel haven serves up mouthwatering rainbow bagels and hearty breakfast sandwiches, perfect for your morning fix.

2712 Gerritsen Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11229 Get directions

@gerritsenbagels

@infatuation

"Technically located across the border in Gerritsen Beach, this local-favorite bagel spot might just have the most delicious rainbow bagel in Brooklyn. It’s fluffier and more flavorful than most of its kind, and on the weekend you can get it with colorful funfetti cream cheese. The breakfast sandwiches here are on-point too, and the pumpernickel everything bagel is dense and chewy, like a loaf of great rye bread. Walk down to the end of Gerritsen Avenue and eat your bagel out on The Point, a secluded beach overlooking Gerritsen Creek. Here, you can experience the strange juxtaposition of standing between the edges of the water and the salt marsh, the Belt Parkway humming in the distance. It’s a bit bizarre, like something out of a sci-fi movie, so you’ll need that bagel to keep you grounded." - carina finn koeppicus

The Best Restaurants In Sheepshead Bay

View Postcard for Gerritsen Bagels Inc

@infatuation

"Technically across the Sheepshead Bay border in Gerritsen Beach, this local-favorite bagel spot might just have the most delicious rainbow bagel in Brooklyn. It’s fluffier and more flavorful than most of its kind, and on the weekend you can get it with colorful funfetti cream cheese. The breakfast sandwiches here are on-point too, and the pumpernickel everything bagel is dense and chewy, like a loaf of great rye bread. Walk down to the end of Gerritsen Avenue and eat your bagel out on The Point, a secluded beach overlooking Gerritsen Creek. Here, you can experience the strange juxtaposition of standing between the edges of the water and the salt marsh, the Belt Parkway humming in the distance. It’s a bizarre experience, like something out of a sci-fi movie, so you’ll need that bagel to keep you grounded. photo credit: Carina Finn" - Max Bonem

Gerritsen Bagels - Review - Sheepshead Bay - New York - The Infatuation

View Postcard for Gerritsen Bagels Inc

Samantha Diz

Google

Horror movie of a morning. Came in and ordered an egg and cheese on a roll with ketchup and Mayo. Then proceeded to ask for Turkey sausage, the guy attending me said they had Turkey bacon so I opted for the bacon egg and cheese on an everything bagel with just butter (two different sandwiches). As they are making it I noticed that they put ketchup and Mayo on the bagel instead of the roll. I notified him and it was corrected. I paid and left. When I got home the egg and cheese was missing from the bag so I came back . He immediately recognized me and gave me the bag with the sandwich. I went all the way home again, just to realize he put bacon in the sandwich. So I went back again and told him I ordered no bacon. He fixed the order didn’t say a word to me. No apology for now having to come 3 times. The lady gives me The new bag and I leave. Just to Come right back a 4th time because he put BACON IN IT AGAIN. This time I went in and told him he made it wrong again. I told him I wanted the money back and his attitude was disgusting he practically threw the money at me and proceeded to blame me for ordering 2 BEC sandwiches. I told him that was impossible because I ordered both sandwiches separately with different instructions as stated in the beginning. I told him he messed up or didn’t understand me correctly . And he insisted I ordered wrong and he was right. I demand he gets fired, there was no apology or compensation. Wasted my time, money, and Gas. I also ordered a muffin with butter . He threw a huge slap of cold butter and left it like that . I got 2 chocolate chip cookies and they tasted horrible. Management needs to changes because this is UNACCEPTABLE .

Steve Vitti

Google

Let’s put it this way, we travel from Philly for these bagels. Four dozen at a clip. Best bagels I’ve ever had.

PrayForAvg

Google

Fantastic Bagel Experience! I recently visited this bagel store and had an incredibly enjoyable experience. The bagels were delicious. The staff was friendly, making the whole visit a pleasure. If you're a bagel enthusiast, this place is definitely worth a try!

Rick Gonzalez (Rick)

Google

I just moved to this area and for the last few weeks I've been buying my breakfast sandwich I don't know if it's because I'm Spanish but I would not think that because the person to help me took my order and right in front of my face he gave my sandwich to someone else then looked at me like if I was asking for free food maybe my service is not really wanted here for some reason I felt very uncomfortable and also felt like because of me being Spanish and I'm only going to spend maybe four or five dollars a day because I'm a poor person maybe my service was not wanted as a customer I'm sorry for coming into your business to try to shop local being that I am a new residence to the area but I've seen already that my support is not wanted

John Mcgall

Google

Yes, you will wait in line. But it is def worth every minute. These bagels are the real deal- slightly sweet with a perfect crust and light,chewy inside. The pumpernickel bagels are nothing short of an act of GOD they are so good. Skip the chains and fake bagel places and treat yourself to a real neighborhood gem.

charles ciccolella

Google

Very nice place for bagels etc., several different types of bagels, you can get them toasted and topped with butter, cream cheese, fast service.

David Rosenduft

Google

Really good bagels, one or two did not make it home. friendly service.

maria reyes

Google

If you are hanging out in south Brooklyn,this breakfast spot is a must go. Fresh bagels, croissants and pastries every morning. I love their whole wheat bagels and their fresh baked muffins are a must try. The place is small and you may even find a short line outside, but it's a local go-to spot so it's expected. The staff is extremely friendly and welcoming. Prices are also reasonable considering the quality of the food.