Kalin S.
Yelp
I lived on Amsterdam between 95th and 96th for 6 years. The whole time I was there I was trying to find a coffee shop that could be my local spot, but after heading to a number of places in the area, I never found one. The day I packed up the car to move upstate, my boyfriend and I wandered around the corner to find a quick breakfast, and were shocked to see a new coffee shop had popped up. It was Gertrude. The outside is unassuming, but cute. Inside, we were greeted by very sweet staff - including a woman (the owner I believe) from Melbourne. It just so happens that my boyfriend is from Melbourne and he is always raving about Australian coffee shops - now that I have been to Gertrude, I understand why.
At Gertrude everything is done with such care. I got a dirty chai and it was delish! The chai is made there and it has bunch of spices including some star anise and clove that give it a little zing that the typical cardamom, cinnamon, ginger don't. My bf got his typical latte and drank it swaying side-to-side like he was in a trance. I also got the porridge - why has no one else mentioned this in other reviews??!! It is sublime! It is also made in-house and is a mix of quinoa, buckwheat, and I believe she said - oats, in coconut milk, and topped with a bunch of unbelievable granola. It was the perfect mix of creamy, crunchy, gluten free, warm, and filling - perfect for a cold day.
Since going for the first time, every time I am in the city I find a reason to come back. I have given multiple friends gift cards to Gertrude because I think it is so fantastic that everyone needs to give it a go.