David R.
Yelp
This place was borderline three stars for me but I decided to be nice and go with four for the time being. What has me on the fence is basically the value. Their food is "pretty good"; i.e. I would not go so far as to call it great, but definitely good enough to keep coming back, so that in my mind is what I refer to as a pretty good meal. The real issue is the food combined with the price; I feel like their prices are just slightly above what the food delivers.
In any case; my wife and I have a place in St Pete Beach so when we're wanting some decent Italian food, we come here. The caprese salad is great; I posted a picture of it. Typically one of us always gets the chicken parm; it's pretty decent and we split it. The other will get something at random. I've found that their 'pompeii' preparation on chicken and veal is pretty great. Blackened prep on salmon is as well. Their Marsala sauce; so so. The other preps I could take or leave.
Their pizzas are great, but pricey.
They have early bird from 4pm to 6pm; definitely don't overlook that, it's a much better value, but limited menu.
If the entrees were perhaps a couple dollars cheaper, I'd consider things priced just right for what you get. I don't think you'll be disappointed regardless though; if you're on the beach and want Italian, don't pass this place up.