Brent Braveman
Google
First visit to Grace Pizza and Shakes at 801 Studewood St. I eat lunch early so was the first customer in exactly at 11:00. Plenty of free parking behind the restaurant.
They have a decent variety of pizzas, or you can create your own. All pizzas are 12 inches. In addition to a full bar, they have a shake menu with fun shakes and “boozy” shakes.
I had a Caesar salad ($11) and pizza ($16) with pepperoni, red onion, and bell pepper. Each ingredient was $2.00. I had a Diet Coke ($3.50) and 2 glasses of wine ($13 each—hey, I took a weekday off!). My total bill was $58.69 but that was with a FREE pizza (see below), taxes, and a 23% tip. The comped pizza was $24, so bill would have been closer to $83. On point for price, I think for a nice pizza, salad, and wine lunch. You can find less expensive, but I thought it was worth it. It is maybe $6 more for the pizza than Star and a different dine in experience. And you don’t have to spend $26 on wine!
The server told me a mistake was made entering my order, so without asking they comped me the whole pizza!!! It was a little wait, but I was not in a hurry. Even without the free pizza the service was great. The bartender/server was friendly and chatted a little but let me enjoy my meal without constant chat.
The salad was delicious, a generous portion, and well dressed with crisp homemade (I assume) croutons, and plenty of Parmesan cheese. I like a little more dressing than some, and this was perfect for me.
The pizza had tons of mozzarella, and perfect amounts of other ingredients and spices. The marinara was a little sweet for my taste but yummy. They may have rushed to deliver the corrected pizza, but the crust was not as crisp as I would have liked but it was close. I think crust is subjective; and I liked the thickness and flavor.
I sat at the bar but liked the dining room space. They had pop playing (Michael Jackson, The Cure, and Forever Young—Alphaville).
Overall, a very good experience and will definitely put it in my rotation for a nicer lunch. It is not an inexpensive lunch, but great pizza and would be a nice place to go with friends for a fun boozy lunch!