Graeter's Ice Cream

Ice cream shop · Olentangy

Graeter's Ice Cream

Ice cream shop · Olentangy

1

2136 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH 43220

Photos

Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null
Graeter's Ice Cream by null

Highlights

Longtime ice cream parlor chain serving small-batch scoops, plus signature sundaes & frozen drinks.  

Featured in Eater
Placeholder
Placeholder

2136 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH 43220 Get directions

graeters.com

$$ · Menu

Information

Static Map

2136 Bethel Rd, Columbus, OH 43220 Get directions

+1 614 442 7622
graeters.com

$$ · Menu

Features

payment credit card
Tap to pay

Last updated

Jul 11, 2025

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2025 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater

"Having grown up in Columbus, Ohio, Graeter’s and Jeni’s were always my go-to spots for grabbing a cold, creamy treat on summer nights. My dad has always been an outspoken Graeter’s devotee, preferring their old-school, no-frills setup and simple, classic options (their cookies and cream can’t be beat, in my opinion)." - Joy Cho

A Recipe for a Jammy, Crunchy Summer Berry Streusel Cake - Eater
View Postcard for Graeter's Ice Cream

Kahina Iguet

Google
Graeter's Ice Cream is an amazing place to delight at. Rich and creamy flavors with top-notch quality. I recommend the 1870 tower is perfectly tasty. They do have a free inside playground for kids. Enjoy ice cream and watch kids at the same time. Friendly staff, too! And clean area. They have outside table if someone like to enjoy nature and fresh air.

Stella Sylvester

Google
Our daughter had her 4th birthday party there and everyone had a blast. Our host was amazing. Each kiddo got to order their own ice cream, pick their own toppings and participate in a science experiment. The room was beautifully decorated so we didn’t have to bring anything extra.

Stacey Rusterholz

Google
The largest Graeters location I’ve been to! It has a spacious seating area, drive thru window, and reservable spaces for gatherings. The best part though is the indoor playground! Be sure to wear socks, as no shoes allowed. There are two party rooms located off the play area

Dawn C

Google
April 24, 2025, we visited this location in the drive-thru...we opted to go here instead of Dairy Queen down the street. According to info we looked up online....scoops of icecream was supposed to be between $2-$4. It was also reported that Graeter's were "generous" with their scoops...that 1 scoop was more like 1.5 scoops & 2 scoops were more like 2.5 scoops. I can tell you THAT WAS A LIE! I got ONE scoop on a SUGAR CONE....my daughter got TWO scoops on a WAFFLE CONE & in a world based on reality there is NO WAY those 2 items should've cost over $13 DOLLARS!! BUT IT DID!!!😒🤯🙄 the icecream was good...taste better than DQ BUTTTT the price is outrageous & I won't be going to ANY Graeter's establishments. I guess the price of the icecream inside of grocery stores was a clue as to how much it would cost at the actual icecream shop! 🤦🏾‍♀️ So to recap: LIKED the icecream, DISLIKED the price.

Ana MC

Google
I celebrated my daughter's birthday at this place, and let me tell you something, it was one of the best experiences we have ever had!! Their staff is so helpful, they decorated and made me feel at ease even when it was a stressful day for this single momma. Their host is AMAZING! She took care of every little detail and made feel everyone so welcomed. Their show (science experiment) about how fairies make the ice cream was something I was not expecting and the kids were impressed and enjoyed every minute of it. Thank you so much for making my daughter's birthday a special one, I really appreciate you guys!

Sy Saqfelhait

Google
This is by far the best customer service I’ve ever experienced. We ordered a milkshake and an ice cream cone and my son dropped his ice cream cone and they immediately replaced it with no questions asked. Then a few minutes later, he realized he didn’t like that flavor so I went back to buy him a new one and they refused my money. This will be my new permanent ice cream joint

Eric Daxon

Google
The Ice cream is great along with the milkshakes , but theres an issue I’ve noticed at this particular location with two of the employees. A heavy set white girl with black hair / green highlights and face piercings , and a mixed race girl with glasses who are just awful at their jobs. Kayla and Ashlynn I beileve are their names , unpleasant atitudes from these two and they make “suggestive” comments towards each other openly. And without fail everytime one of them did my order something would be wrong , management should be more selective of who they hire in my opinion.

Babul Ali

Google
Amazing service and great tasting ice cream. Laila, who served us went out of her way to make sure our experience here was a memorable one. We had 5 different ice cream flavours and they were all amazing. A great play area for the kids too. We'll definitely be back.