HN S.
Yelp
Nicky's is your classic diner. I was in the court house area today (no worries, wasn't in court) and walked into the Grant Building with the intent on giving the Grant Street Tavern a try for lunch when I noticed this place. It looked pretty popular so I decided to give it a try instead.
My waitress, Marlene, greeted me almost immediately by asking me what I'd like to have. I appreciate the attention much more than waiting so I replied as politely as I could "Can I start with a menu please?" After looking over the menu I decided a burger was probably the safest thing to order when in a deli. Despite the place being relatively busy, the waitress took my order within a minute of my setting down the menu and five minutes later, I had a Mushroom Provolone Burger in front of me.
I wasn't really expecting much and was pretty impressed with what I got for $6.69 (tax included). The bun and the tomato was fresh, the mushrooms were plentiful and a nice melted slice of provolone covered a burger that you could tell was hand pressed (not a frozen patty). It was cooked all the way through while still maintaining a juicy bite.
I give it a four star for quick service, good value for your dollar and a burger that exceeded my expectations.