Jimmy N.
Yelp
5-star price, 3.5-star flavor.
Positives:
Ordered carry-out via online order. It showed a 45min ETA for pickup time, and they had it ready in almost exactly, maybe 5 minutes later, and we asked for ours extra crispy / well done.
The crust was fantastic. Great dough flavor, and great crispness for the most part.
Not positive or negative:
Be aware this is NOT "typical" New York style pizza. Much lighter on the cheese and heavier on the sauce than most might be used to. It seemed like the sauce may have been on top too - not like Detroit style, but reminiscent of it. Just be aware, if you're planning to bring any small picky eaters along.
Negatives:
Whoever cut our pizza must have been doing so for their first time - it was the worst cut I've ever had on a pizza, no exaggeration. We did request "double cut" (one of the presented buttons/options online - not like we wrote in some odd special request), but the cuts were extremely haphazard, and nowhere close to being through the crust. We had to fight with a pizza cutter on our own to get ANY slice out of the box.
The big one... The Sauce. Unfortunately, we really didn't like the red sauce on this pizza. My wife couldn't even finish a whole slice, and I was very disappointed. If it weren't for this, the bad cut would be a non-issue, and this probably would have been a 4-5 star review. But the flavor of this sauce was really that off-putting.
I'd suggest skipping this place and checking out some of the other nearby options to try your luck.