Scott M.
Yelp
As a general store, since that's what it claims to be, I would actually award only 1 star, since it probably has less groceries and general merchandise than your average convenience store. It, however, has lots of cold beer and a fair selection of wine, along with a shelf of high priced organic resale foods - no bread, no eggs or cheese (unless I missed them among the coolers full of cold cases of beer), no produce or meat, no toilet paper or paper towels; pretty much only what you can fit in the 150 square feet or so of space they allot for store merchandise. The rest of the large building is devoted to dining and drinking space for their bar and grill, which was closed at the time due to the holidays.
Years ago we spent time on the island and counted on the store to provide much of what we needed. This time, we rented a cabin and brought some groceries, but planned on supplementing from the store to support the island economy. Since we don't drink, that was a total bust. I can recommend the cookies and cold beverages, but that's about it. We headed for Safeway, with another ferry ride, to get some more basics, which broke the lovely spell the island had cast upon us. Wise up guys, your days are numbered - sooner or later a real store will appear and your eatery will be just another trendy business that's a major hassle to get to. And trust me, that store will likely sell good sandwiches and soups, too, even during the holidays.
PS Per their 2017 online video where they say they have everything an islander would need or can explain how to do without it, I would really like the owner to explain to me how to get along without the numerous products they don't carry. However, the place is beautiful, clean and the staff is friendly.