Catherine L.
Yelp
I can't decide between two and three stars for Paddy Shack, which is sort of the restaurant part of the Half Time Rec. Our waiter was a great fellow, so he gets a star. Of course, the black and tans were good, as they have been for decades, another star. But I was so very disappointed in the food.
My husband had the cod and chips. I tasted a bit of the cod, which looked delicious but tasted more like icky fish than yummy fish. I asked him if all the rest of the fish tasted like that and he said "yes." He's used to sushi so he was able to stomach the flavor, however I would have sent it back if I had gotten it. He said the fish breading was very good and he devoured the chips. He wouldn't touch the shot glass full of smashed peas. I don't blame him. They were minty and strange.
I ordered the shepard's pie. It was lava-like. Now, I usually have the opposite problem, but this little casserole was so hot that if I had dropped it in my lap I'd have had to do a Macdonald's and sue them for burned skin. While it cooled, I ate the brown bread, which I had really looked forward to, as I ate loaves of it in Ireland years ago. Sadly, this had no relation to that rustic bread. This was flavorless, smooth and dense and tasted like it had a maple glaze on it. My husband had mostly consumed his fish before I could eat my "pie," but after all that waiting, I was sad. The dish consisted of a big pile of mashed potatoes with barely an inch of mostly-gravy stew down at the bottom. Either I had baked my taste buds, or it just had no taste. Regardless, it was pretty disappointing.
There were a lot of other things on the menu that looked interesting, and I wouldn't mind trying them, if we ever go back to eat. Incidentally, my husband and I were regulars at the Rec back in the 80s and 90s, in the heyday of the Irish bands. The place hasn't changed that much, except for a number of high tables and stools and a modified bar. It looks a little cleaner too, (although I never went in there during daylight anyway, so don't know for certain). Apparently they don't often have Irish music anymore, so our nostalgia trip was not fully realized.