Dedicated C.
Google
A Chicago Transplant Where the Chicken Shines, But Everything Else Falls Short
Overall Rating: 3/5 stars (Food pulls it up; service and value drag it down)
As someone originally from Chicago, I have a soft spot for Harold’s Chicken Shack.
The food is undeniably the highlight and the only reason this place gets any stars from me. The wings are consistently flavorful, crispy on the outside, juicy inside, and fried to order just like the classic Harold’s style. That signature mild sauce ties it all together perfectly.
But that’s where the positives end. Service is consistently subpar. The cashiers often come across as disinterested or outright grumpy like they’re doing you a favor by taking your order, it’s especially grating here.
The real slap in the face is the pricing. Charging $15 for 4 wings or $20 for 8? That’s outrageous compared to original Chicago spots, where wing dinners often run much lower. Even accounting for inflation and regional differences, these prices feel inflated especially since this location started higher than Chicago originals and then hiked them further after expanding with a bar. For a family order (say, six 4-piece wing meals), you’re looking at $90+ easily. In an era of rising costs, I get that businesses adjust, but this crosses into exploitative territory when the core experience is still basic takeout style.
If the business is thriving and lines are out the door, owners can charge what the market bears. But for me? I’ll pass. There are too many places delivering great fried chicken without the attitude or the wallet shock.
Support businesses that earn it through value and respect, not just nostalgia or convenience. As a Chicago expat, this one hurts. the food reminds me of home, but the rest makes me want to hop a flight back for the real deal at a fair price.