Amanda B.
Yelp
The husband and I haven't had the chance to buy directly from the Heartbreakers restaurant, but we've ordered their pizza kits a few times through Burrow Shop's online grocery store. They're Burrow Shop's Mealshare items, which means when you buy them, Burrow Shop provides one simple, healthy meal to a youth in need through Mealshare. Win win win!
We've tried the pepperoni and the "Fun-Guy" pizzas, and there's also a plain cheese option. The make-at-home kits come with two pizza doughs, cheese, and sauce, $24-28 per kit. The pepperoni pizza kit comes with tomato sauce, aged fresh mozzarella, dry-cured pepperoni, Grana Padano, and fresh basil. The "Fun-Guy" is a white pizza with toasted mushroom cream instead of tomato sauce, whole milk mozzarella, Le Coprin mushrooms (cinnamon cap, phoenix oyster, king eryngii), Grana Padano, and fresh parsley. I think there's actually a couple kinds of mozzarella (regular pizza mozzarella and fresh mozzarella, or another soft cheese I embarrassingly can't identify, so they're more like 3-cheese). They also come with instructions, including leaving it out for 2- to 3-hours, so plan accordingly.
The first time around, we only made one pepperoni pizza and didn't have a rolling pin, so we really messed up the dough and poked a ton of holes in it, which was both hilarious and a learning experience, but still tasted great. After trying to stretch it out with our hands, we realized we should've just made both, but there wasn't enough time (aka we were hangry) to let the other one sit out. We learned quickly and just made one each the next few times we got them (last time was with a rolling pin that I got as an early Christmas gift to help this problem). The pizzas are meant to be rolled out as thinly as possible, so it's really not as big or heavy as you might think, but take that from someone who eats a lot lol
Both pizzas are very different but equally delicious. The second time we had the mushroom pizza, my husband added some deli meat to his, which is always a plus of making them yourself at home and adding whatever you want.
I normally choose thin crust pizzas whenever I have the option, so these are totally my kind of pizza. I wish there was more cheese, but I eat cheese in excessive amounts, so I'm sure it's the normal amount for non-cheese-obsessed folks. I really appreciate the different cheeses, high-quality pepperoni and mushrooms, and great sauces. The husband is a big pizza guy, so he really just wishes there was more, but other than that, we think they're great and can't wait to try them freshly made by Heartbreakers whenever this pandemic lets up!