Rusty R.
Yelp
I've been living in NYC for 15 years, so I'm at the point where, on occasion, I seek out some of the more off the beaten path "attractions". I decided to trek to Staten Island to explore Historic Richmond Town. I expected a smaller version of Historic Williamsburg or Mystic Seaport.
Historic Richmond Town is a wonderful idea poorly executed.
I arrived to discover that of the 23 historic structures on site, ONE was open to the public. ONE. This was the carpenter's shop. A man was working there and did a fabulous job explaining woodworking of the day. There was not a single costumed interpreter in the entire rest of the "town". In fact, between the lack of people and the fact that the buildings were all closed, it was quite a ghost town.
I then had a little bit of time to kill before my 1:30 tour (considering I had prepare to visit several homes which as it turns out were all locked up). 1:30 came and went, though I was at the designated meeting spot. Finally I returned to the gift shop (where you pay admission) and asked what was going on. I was then told that, "maybe there wouldn't be a tour - maybe the guide already left." Left? I was told he'd issue me a refund. Fine, but not fine because I just paid like $15 bridge toll to come to this place. Fortunately, he then discovered that the guide was in fact there and would commence the tour shortly.
The tour was advertised as: "America was built on its stomach and made in the kitchen. Explore how food was picked, prepared, preserved, and presented in this tour focused on kitchens and food." This did not happen. Not even remotely.
My guide. Sarah, was personable, friendly, and polite. As there were only 5 of us on the tour, we were not rushed or anything. We visited 4-5 buildings, which she did have a key to grant us entry to see inside (sans costumed interpreters). Food was not discussed.
Guide informed us that living history / costumed interpreters happen but once a month on "special occasions". I, along with the others on the tour, were blindsided by this.
The site also needs some TLC. To get to certain buildings. you have to cross a busy street, walk through weeds along the shoulder of the road, etc. I mean, I'm sure they're running on a shoestring, but is it really not possible to either create a sidewalk or at least mow the weeds?
Ok so the positives are:
1. Great buildings
2. Good tour guide
3. Great interpreter (the ONE that was actually there)
Negatives
1. Zero organization/coordination
2. Tour topic not as advertised
3. Site all but a ghost town, this needs to be a functioning living history museum or the website needs to clearly say that this is NOT, but once a month.
Ultimately, not recommended.