Charlotte S.
Yelp
Honke Shibato's unagi is one of those "must-try-at-least-once" kinds of things, along the same vein as Kobe beef and ramen. Sure, you could probably get it anywhere in Japan but wouldn't it be best to try it the way the pros make it? And with a 300-year-old legacy, you know Honke Shibato is one of the pros. It's with this mindset that we ventured out to try them.
We arrived early and didn't have to wait at all. Three women warmly greeted us and made us feel at home right away. They shuffled us in and one of them escorted us up in an escalator into a warm room. Before we stepped in, she asked us to take off our shoes and we entered a cozy room with low-set tables. It reminded me of a traditional household I'd see in anime and whatnot. It was also the first time in our trip that we experienced anything like it.
We ordered the Osaka-Mamushi set and a separate order of umaki. The waitress never left the room, despite the kitchen being somewhere else in the building, and was very attentive the entire time. While we did have to wait for a bit, she always kept us updated and made sure our cups of tea were never empty. Eventually, our food came and it was delicious! The eel in the Osaka-Mamushi set was crispy on the outside, and soft inside - something I've never experienced outside of this restaurant. You could tell that it was cooked with care (and potentially over a grill?). Although the sauce on top was thinner than most restaurants, it was not any less flavourful. The umaki was good as well but it paled in comparison to the Osaka-Mamushi set - mostly because you could barely taste the eel in it.
Overall, it was a delicious meal and a terrific experience. That being said, it feels like another one of those things that you go to just the once to say that you've tried it.
There's a minimum ¥ amount that you must order (unfortunately, I don't quite remember the amount at this point) and each item on the menu is quite pricey. While the unagi was very good and did have a characteristic that I haven't found elsewhere (i.e. crispy outside, soft inside), that characteristic is also not that crucial to my enjoyment of the dish. Perhaps I'm just not an unagi connoisseur - I can appreciate the difference but I personally don't feel like it warrants that steep of a price hike.
Personally, I'm glad to have experienced it and would recommend you going for the experience. But if you are like me - not a unagi connoisseur - and looking for something more cost-effective, maybe try somewhere else...