Jaewon Yoon
Google
Hands down the best dining experience I had in Reykjavik.
A few of the restaurants I checked out in Reykjavik were unbearably salty and/or gamey and we had to leave after a few bites of the $40+/person meal (could be due to our taste as tourists differing that of the locals), but the food at Hosiló just blew our minds. It was not only edible but every bite was a joyful discovery.
We ordered Lamb Tartare as appetizer, Grilled Portobello Mushroom, and Grilled Cod. Then Lamb Tartare was by far my favorite dish. The raw lamb meat had its unique taste without being annoyingly gamey. The anchovys and fresh lemon squeeze made the dish refreshing, balanced well with the rich mayo based sauce (I'm guessing). The crusty yet chewy croutons made the texture of each bite all the more interesting, and even the parsley sprinkled on top were fresh and delightfully fragrant.
Grilled Portobello Mushroom actually had a few different types of mushrooms in the dish. Instead of overpowering the mushroom with spice and sauce, the dish let the flavors of its ingredients stand out, which I appreciated.
The Grilled Cod dish was also amazing. It was cooked just right, not too melty or rubbery. The broccoli, beets, and hand made potato chips added to the dish unexpectedly made good companions for the fish, adding different layers of sweet, savory, and crunchy to each bite. I had absolute fun trying out different combinations throughout my meal. Was too full to try desserts but no doubt the fig pudding would have been excellent too.
The decor was cozy, with lots of plants placed throughout the space. Loved the ambient music selections, that didn't interfere with the dining experience in any way (really not a fan of loud music when eating). Also, would like to point out that some of the older negative reviews here that made us hesitant to visit Hosiló are either unwarranted or no longer relevant. Totally forgot to take a picture of the menu, but there were 3-4 options each for appetizer, entre, and dessert, and had both English and Icelandic versions of the menu. The menu descriptions were straightforward, and we had no issues communicating with the staff, who were all very cordial and made the dining experience a good balance of private and supportive.