James S.
Yelp
While I did not take notes during my stay at the Theodore, I do recall generally positive feelings about the Hotel. The biggest issues, which stuck with me, regarded room size and the bill. One seemed kind of small, and the other, kind of big. Seeing the 3 1/2 Stars here on Yelp, I'd tend to agree. There is much to like here, but there's a bit of hesitation to go with 4.
Customer service was great, and the staff deserves tons of stars. An out-of-left-field request to them was handled with the ease of a seasoned pro. Also, the front desk staff easily answered my off-the-cuff query as to the name of the Hotel Theodore. This engendered a certain confidence and charm.
It's a vintage building, and occasionally one can see the limitations of that charm. The plumbing is updated, of course, and it's fun to see some period fixtures, too. The room is kind of small, no doubt about it. But it is comfortable. The TV against the wall appears rather huge, which can be nice. Otherwise, things feel very hip and contemporary.
They have a fun Happy Hour type situation in the Lobby, compliments of the Hotel. Never had a chance to imbibe, but it's a lovely, cozy set-up that I wished I could have experienced. Adjoining this lobby is the restaurant bar and restaurant. The restaurant deserves its own review, but I can say here that the bar is a welcome and convenient venue to meet.
Yes, I am aware of the day-job of the owner of the Theodore. And, at first I wondered how, if at all, that should effect my review. Ultimately, I prefer to let my impressions regarding the Hotel dictate the review, rather than anything else. I definitely liked the Hotel, and would definitely consider coming back.