Marcel Mairhofer
Google
We visited Ikarus to celebrate our anniversary on the 4th of July— our very first time dining at a Michelin-starred restaurant. Expectations were high. Unfortunately, the experience left us disappointed.
From the moment we told the sommelier we’d only be drinking water (for health reasons), the atmosphere shifted. One server in particular acted noticeably distant. Eye contact was minimal, and the descriptions of the dishes at our table were far shorter than what we overheard at nearby tables with wine pairings. It left us with the uncomfortable feeling of being treated as “lesser guests.”
Some dishes were good — the carabinero, the hake, the bread, and the desserts. But none of the courses tasted special or delivered a “wow” moment. A piece of raw toro was too large to eat in one bite, yet too sinewy to bite through — it slipped off the base and had to be pulled apart by hand. A scallop course smelled intensely fishy, to the point where my partner couldn’t eat it. Small details, like a visible vinaigrette smear on the side of a serving pedestal, felt off-brand for this level of fine dining. The petit fours at the end tasted no different from store-bought candy.
One highlight: a blonde female server (possibly the maître d’) was exceptionally warm and welcoming.
I shared this feedback privately with the restaurant before posting this review. The response was polite yet underwhelming — essentially: “Sorry it didn’t meet your expectations. We still hope you’ll return.”
All in all, for a restaurant with 2 Michelin stars and the associated price point, this visit didn’t come close to delivering the quality or experience we hoped for. We might have been at a bad moment, so it’d be unjust to condemn the whole restaurant for eternity. But trying it out again is not worth it for us, given our experience and the high price point.