Katrina V.
Yelp
I've been to Il Fornaio three times in the past 2 months. Twice at the Irvine location for customer meetings, but this recent time was in my hometown with my fiance for a date night. I haven't been to this location in years, and I vividly remember having just an OK experience the last time (also confirmed the sentiment as I reread my last review). That being said, I felt like an updated review was warranted since I had a much better experience this time around.
We had dinner reservations for 5:15pm on a Saturday night. Il Fornaio hasn't changed one bit. It's maintained its classiness over the years and aged quite well. When we sat at our table, there must've been 10 customers total in the entire restaurant. The restaurant quickly picked up, and as soon as you know it, the place was packed.
Service was excellent. Food came out in a timely manner, and our server was friendly and incredibly attentive. However, she seemed to be very diplomatic about her opinions on certain food items, so I had a hard time really choosing what to eat. I also wished that she brought to attention the menu with the specials, because I completely missed it. I had already placed my order for my entree by the time I saw what were the specials. (I would've gotten the lobster ravioli if I had known about them).
We shared the polpettine and calamari. The polpettine appetizer consisted of 3 beef meatballs in marinara sauce over soft polenta. The beef meetballs were particularly great. They had a nice smokiness to them. Enjoyed the calamari for the most part. The pieces were meaty and breaded well, but whoever prepared them had a heavy hand with the salt.
I was pretty stuffed with appetizers, so I opted for a caesar salad with anchovies. It was a very traditional caesar, which I enjoyed.
My fiance got braised short rib ravioli. This was a very interesting dish. Not saying it wasn't tasty, but it didn't taste Italian to me. It was like a beef dumpling stew.