Amy L.
Yelp
I think what confuses me is reading the other reviews on here and trying to decide if we just had an off night experience or if those few people got lucky. Btw I've really been looking forward to this place opening because all the other pizza places nearby have a lot of crust which I'm not a fan of. Took my dad last night, his last night in town, and went in at 5:10pm because I had a work call at 7, thinking 1.5 hours for a quick pizza was sufficient. Our experience was bizarre at best but mostly just disappointing. We walked in and were nicely greeted by one of the owners (or what looks to be one of the owners from the website pic). The man assigned to take care of our table was just ODD energetically form the start which continued through "service." It felt a little bit like asking for what you wanted was an imposition, not because he said so, but because of the odd look you'd receive when you'd said something like...is there a make your own pizza option...to which he replied, I guess we could use this one and add mushrooms...or asking for vinegar because the "salad" was a large family style plate of nicely quartered romaine hearts,upon which a heap of red onion, 4 halved tomato, a few pieces of cucumber, a handful of tiny olives were placed then drowned in flavorless oil(not even sure it was olive when I'm honest) and zero acid as far as I could tell. It tasted like store bought "Italian" dressing but without even the flavorful part. Maybe they just mixed a bad batch-dunno. In the meanwhile, our waters were obsessively filled, like take one sip and they're there filing it back up-waaaay too much. The pizza arrived almost 40 minutes after it was ordered. We both ordered diavolos which I lived on in Italy but it just tasted like SALT. On top of that, the weird guy asked me if I wanted him to but my pizza (we'd already asked for it to be cut) and started going to do it without my answer which was of course, no(weird) The crust was floppy and undercooked and the pizza was inedible. Literally. Like just gross. We got them to go because I didn't want to get into why don't you like it etc. They went straight in the bin at home after a 60+$ tab and we actually ordered two dependably ok delivery pizzas which we devoured while I did the call (that I was then late for). Speaking of the tab, I was treating my dad, so I handed aforementioned man my card to pay, but when he brought it back, he looked at me and said, you don't need to sign, and handed my card and the receipt to my dad instead of to me. Like, in the 1 minute he was gone he forgot that I paid-just gonna say there was this SERIOUSLY odd/ misogynistic tone over the course of the visit and this just took the cake. What's bizarre is these people are clearly authentic Italian folks who have made, what looked to be, a super cute place. I mean the owner was yammering away to someone either on the phone or in person most of the time we were there, in Italian, so definite legit...but man, I just don't know what else to say. Hope others have a better experience.