Wally P.
Yelp
Oak Street Bootmakers make the best shoe you will find anywhere in Chicago. Until now, however, it was really tough to find a pair. I was first in line when their flagship store - Independence - opened, and it did not disappoint.
Although the store had just opened, they had full size runs of most of their shoes. In the few cases where they did not, they had a sample on the floor, along with a promise of easy and efficient delivery of any size.
On to the shoes. Oh, the shoes. The leather comes from the Horween leather factory, only a couple of miles away from the store. Handcrafted in the U.S. (Maine?), their quality is unmatched. This was my first time dealing with Chromexcel leather, but it will definitely not be the last. It is a very good blend of shine, finish, comfort, and toughness.
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, but, in my opinion, OSB make a great-looking shoe. Although they only have a few different styles, they offer great variety through different colors, soles, and finishes. Make sure to try out as many styles as you can, you may be surprised. I walked out with a pair of Loden (green) Vibram sole oxfords, even though that was not on my initial list to try on. Everything I tried on looked great, but I had to make a decision at some point. I will definitely be going back in the fall for a pair of lace-up boots.
Besides shoes, Independence also sells other menswear. Gitman Bros. shirts, vintage Levi's, that kind of stuff. Not quite the selection of Haberdash or Penelope's, for example, but definitely not bad.
The prices are reasonable. $300 is quite a bit of money, but for a pair of good, durable, American-made leather shoes, you should not expect to spend much less.
The service was great. Shout outs to Timothy for putting up with me while I tried on every pair of shoes they had. He was very knowledgeable, despite the store being so new. A+ on the staff training process.
As a side note, this block of Oak Street is becoming the go-to place for menswear. Not the most wallet-friendly destination, but with Independence, Paul Stuart, George Greene, etc. this street has it all.