Mackenzie J.
Yelp
Just left this location to get some late night treats. This was my first experience at an Insomnia Cookies, and although I will give the other locations in the DC area a shot, I will never return to the O street location due to the horrible customer service provided by a cashier named Dani (unsure on spelling of name). This occurred Friday 6/28 at approx 11pm, and I did inform the manager. I would also like to preface this review that at no time was I rude or being difficult- I have worked in customer service/food service for 10+ years.
Me and my significant other have a huge sweet tooth. I'm a sugar cookie fanatic, so when I was waiting in line and heard the woman at the counter tell the customers in front of me she was out of sugar cookies bc they were just put in the oven, I got super excited and asked how long they would take to bake, I was told 10 minutes. The woman behind the counter seemed instantly annoyed that I asked this question. When my significant other came out of the bathroom, we took a moment to look at the menu to decide what we wanted (there was no one behind us in line btw). We took no more than 2 minutes to decide, and asked a couple typical questions about the menu. The whole time the cashier was tapping her finger and impatient as hell. My SO got a Bigwich (icing in the middle of 2 cookies) and I excitedly ordered 6 sugar cookies, telling Dani I would wait for them to come out of the oven since they'd be fresh. At the last minute, we added a bottle of 2% milk ($3.70, highway robbery!!) and that pissed Ms. Sunshine Dani off even more. While waiting for my fresh sugar cookies, I stepped outside to smoke a cigarette and my SO ate his cookie sandwich, which he said tasted great.
Went back inside as Dani was packaging my cookies in the back. She came out saying "they are still really soft" and had 3 cookies each in 2 small individual cookie bags.... instantly ruining the fresh cookies and smashing them. I had seen the couple before me get a box, so I asked her if I could have one as they were getting smashed. "We are out of small boxes" she said. "Oh but I saw the couple before me leave with a box..." I replied. "A 24 count box?!" She asked me rudely, and she seemed like that was a crazy question, and with her bad attitude and my already poor experience, I left disappointed.
As I got to my car, I changed my mind and decided I did in fact want that box to try and preserve what I could of the shape of the fresh cookies (which, see pictures, I wasn't really able to lol). I walked in and politely told Dani "actually I will take that box"... and she stormed to the back and grabbed one, and told me "I'm technically not allowed to give you this size box"... wanting to say a lot more than I did (like "did you really not realize my cookies were smashed putting them in 2 small bags?!" "Don't you just give a customer a box when they ask?!" Etc....) wanting to get the hell out of there, I mumbled "hmm I guess".... and this rude woman had the audacity to MOCK me "I guessssss" she said in a mocking voice.
Being caught off guard, my comeback was really lame and I just mocked her right back. As I was leaving, there were two employees outside smoking cigarettes, and luckily one was the manager on duty. I informed him as politely as possible of my poor experience, Dani's horrible attitude, and that we would not be back. He didn't seem to care and had a smirk the whole conversation. I left after that, just over the whole experience.
Listen, I don't write too many reviews, especially of this length nor do I try to take fast food places too seriously. Especially for some cookies. But honestly my whole order for 3 things was $22 freaking dollars.... and being a paying customer and all I would at least expect to be respected and treated as such, especially when I was nothing but kind. I'm hoping I just caught Dani on a bad night, but I sincerely hope management takes this complaint seriously and invests in some training for this horrible cashier with a serious attitude problem. Don't mock customers, Dani. It's unbecoming. Oh, and after all that the sugar cookies were just alright.