Island Creamery New Jersey

They have a ton of flavors and the staff was super nice! Note: Nut allergy flavors were clearly identified but they do not carry gluten free or vegan flavors. Bonus points for the ice cream bird🍦🐦

It's one of my favorite Ice Cream places in Jersey area!!! The owners will make you feel at home the moment you walk in. I'm sure all of their flavors are delightful. However, my 2 favorite Rum Raisins and Coconut are to die for.

Wish I could give this place 6 stars! Such kind people, showed up ten minutes before closing and they treated us like the most important people in the world!!! Place is very clean and ice cream was delicious! Can't recommend enough. Outdoor seating and a beautiful aesthetic.

Moments ago I went into Island Creamery in Atlantic City, New Jersey. And I was treated like crap. Not only was the lady working the counter was rude, and did not seem interested in anything that I had to say. Her manager, some guy working with her was rude, and not interested in helping me as the new customer to their Ice Cream Shop. Nothing was wrong with the ice cream shop’s bathroom. I needed to use it, she was rude, looked at the guy. The guy looked at me with a wild expression. Shakes his head know. I reminded that I am customer. Then he goes no, the bathroom is not for the public. Then I go, “why is there a sign up that says restrooms this way?” The staff here is very unprofessional. No customer service skills, bad attitude. I was planning to buy my staff of U. S. POLICE FIRE EMS FOUNDATION some ice cream. But after I was treated unfairly. I did not want to do business there. I will never go to this ice cream shop again. They’ve lost me, and my staff as a customer. I would definitely not recommend Island Ice Cream Shop to anyone that asks. Sincerely, T. S.President U. S. POLICE FIRE EMS FOUNDATION

Since June I have ordered 3 ice cream cakes from Island creamery, every single one of them were outstanding looking and tasting! Their prices are so affordable and the best part is the overall quality and taste. The shop is kept very clean and staff is always helpful. Definitely worth taking the family to get some ice cream here!

We came in mid-evening for some ice cream cones and a milkshake. The staff was super helpful in picking out flavors and toppings and putting together some great cones (with cups for backup). We also got a hand-scooped chocolate and peanut butter milkshake. It was awesome. I'd kinda like another now, as I write this. Prices were reasonable. All good. Bonus points: they were playing the Avatar animated series on the TV while we were in. Cool shop.

We stopped by mid-evening for some ice cream and a milkshake, but honestly, it wasn’t a great experience. The staff seemed disinterested and not very helpful when it came to choosing flavors or toppings—just going through the motions. The cones were sloppily made, and even though they gave us cups, it felt more like they were rushing us out than trying to be helpful. The milkshake? Disappointing. It was supposed to be chocolate and peanut butter, but it tasted bland and overly thick—more like a melted mess than an actual shake. Definitely not something I’d want again. Prices weren’t outrageous, but for the quality and service, it didn’t feel worth it. And while the Avatar cartoon playing on the TV might’ve been a nice touch for some, it felt more like a distraction from the lack of atmosphere and customer engagement. Won’t be in a hurry to come back.

Delicious milkshake and ice cream - my family took a break from the beach and mini golf to get some tasty ice cream. The owner was great to talk to and let us try some of the flavors.