Italianette Pizza

A great local spot that gives young people a shot at working in the real world. A throwback to Pizza Hut in the 80s with red plastic cups and quality food. Highly recommend the Taco Pizza and Nachos. Most of the negative reviews around timeliness can be chalked up to the fact that this place stays BUSY! The wait can be mitigated by calling ahead. Great place, great food, great staff!

Wow I’m not sure where to even begin on this review! I gave 2 stars cause the employee was nice. Let’s get to the point! I ordered food yesterday 1 lasagna 2 spaghetti dinners and a medium deluxe pizza. It took 25 minutes. The lady said my order is ready so I leave and go home. I get home realizing they forgot my lasagna so I called up there and she said sorry and I go back to get it. Tell me this, Why is the prices online different from the store? I didn’t catch it til it was too late. The medium pizza deluxe is $12.49 so why she charge me $11.49 plus $6?? The meatballs were supposed to be 0.50 but she charge me 0.75. Then it has a technology fee of $2.33. I’ve never ever heard of that! It’s false advertising!! The food was not good! $60 in the trash! NEVER AGAIN IN MY LIFE WILL THEY GET BUSINESS FROM ME! Wasting my time and money!

I grew up on this food. Hadn't been here in years. Shared with a first-timer, and they loved it too!

This place is truly a gem and worth visiting. They are a truly hometown pizza, and they have consistently delivered every single time. They have a standard of quality and I know what to expect every time! Delicious pizza. Plus I used to play baseball for krimmers back when I was a kid, so technically, I should get free pizza for life, but you know, we can't all get what we want i guess. I suppose I'll just have to keep going there for delicious food.And I recommend you definitely check this place out!

One of the best pizzas I have ever had plus we ordered before closing and they stayed open for us! It was further away than I realized. The staff are so kind!

I order 2 small pizzas on July 17th for take out. I have lived in Silverton for over 50 years and have always praised Italianette Pizza. Yesterday the pizza was so bad I don't know if I will return. It was burnt. This is not what I am accustom to. Your pizza was always the best in town. I am not sure what is going on but prices on the rise you would expect better.

Excellent food. The pizza is top notch. Been eating here for over thirty years!

If you’re ever in Cincinnati, with or without a large group, and want amazing pizza, visit Krimmer's Italianette Pizza Silverton location! I had made reservations for 28 and they never hesitated. We ended up with 22 for dinner! Absolutely delicious pizza, outstanding and prompt service from our waitress and great atmosphere. We loved it!

Italianette has always been one of my favorite pizza places in Cincinnati. I haven't been in a while but I'm glad nothing has changed! Food it's still amazing and the staff is still friendly. I need to start coming back more regularly.

Food was good. Servers were not very attentive even though they were not very busy. We had a pizza and sides

Pizza is always one of the best. Every pizza has a great flavor. I have been going to italianette Since 1976. Used to get my beer there. Lol

A perfect little pizza parlor in Cincinnati with charming looks and a cozy atmosphere. The pizza and breadsticks were phenomenal. Hand tossed and hand rolled to perfection. The cheese and pepperoni were high quality. Even the bacon and ham on the Hawaiian was appreciated. The service was a little slow but I can't complain when they had a moderate crowd with tons of takeout orders going out the front. The calzones also looked great at our neighbor table. This is a picture perfect pizza parlor I can happily visit again when in town.

If I could give it 10 stars, I would. And then I'd come back tomorrow and give it 10 more. I had The Big Gripp pizza, and somewhere between the first bite and the last, I achieved inner peace. It was so good I considered legally changing my name to Big Gripp. It gave me a hug from the inside.

This place was ok. Restaurant was cold. Ordered pasta it came out cold. Was very bland. Ordered the pizza it was good. The sausage was spicy. They charged me $1.28 to use my debt card. Weird. It was just ok.

Good alternative to all the chain pizza restaurants. If you like bacon on your pizza you will love the bacon at Italianette. Service was good as well.

This place looks unassuming. The first person I see is an Italian mother smiling and waving to me as I walk in the door. I knew it was going to be good. I ordered up a meatball hoagie and loaded wedge fries. The waitress was very friendly and made the experience even more special. The food was awesome. Worth every penny of the $15. I took a raspberry white chocolate cake to go. Highly recommend this place.

Our group, the PCY Foodies, went to Krimmers Italianette Pizza in College Hill. Other than being a little cool inside, our experience was wonderful. The server was on the ball, even with us sitting in another room because of the size of our party. The group had a variety of salads sandwiches and, of course, pizzas. I had the Tuesday lunch special of a specialty pizza(Deluxe Seven) and a refillable soft drink. My total bill, including tax was $11.85 and was worth every cent. I'm a little picky about pizza, but I like the crust, sauce, and the topping. IMO and for my taste, it is one of the better pizzas in town.

I was in town and happened across Italianette Pizza. Walked in 30 minutes before closing and they were so nice. Took my order and I had my pizza in 20 minutes. It was delicious! Will go back again next time I'm in Cincy.

I've never dined in however, over the years my work has ordered from Italianette Pizza and it's been solid. Recently, we had a family size pepperoni pizza delivered and it was awesome. Their signature sauce has hints of garlic and I love their crust. It's not to thick/thin but just right. In the past, I've tried their pasta (spaghetti) with bread sticks and wings. Both delish. I'd have to say that this place is off the beaten path in Silverton but word of mouth definitely has spread out. If you have not tried it, I highly recommend you should. Not fancy, but quality is worth the reasonable pricing. In my opinion, they are underrated.

Great pizza in silverton reasonable priced thin crust pizza definitely at step above for some of the other pizza options in area!

Great food! service is always good. Best pizza in town. Don't miss it.you can't go wrong there

My favorite pizza in the city. Small strips of bacon on the pizza, yes please. The sausage is incredible. The best pizza ever.

I am going to shoot straight with you. Is Krimmers the best pizza in the entire world? Sadly no. But is it soooooo good and a certified gem for our area? Absolutely! Krimmers makes fantastic pizza and is 100% worth dining in or getting to-go. I'd put it head to head with A LOT of pizza in our city and know that it'll win.

We'll just stopped back for another pie considering I had a Reach coupon and who doesn't like a good coupon. It was $16.99 for a large 2 topping. Now if you order up to 3 more you get them at $11.99, wow but I can't eat 4 large pies. We'll I knew no need for extra cheese since they always do that up right. And I don't like fresh mushrooms on my pizza, can here baby, east coast style as I has always had mine served. Even Pizza Hut did canned. So I went with double pepperoni thinking it would look like Donato's or close and I always like my meat on top of the cheese and that is just how I ordered led it otherwise they hide it under. I wish I put another pic on here. The picture below was pretty much what I got. And when I checked the menu, the coupon saved me a whopping 57 cents!!!! What a let down. So sorry a once fav but now you are back in the pack and drop to a 3 star. Service was good but when asked about the amount of pepperoni she said it was their double amount. I should have called over the Mgr and just sent it back. Ambiance is just ok, and usually service and the pie bring it up in the rating for me, but today it brought it to what it is, a three. I won't be rushing back unless it is for a cheese pizza.

First of all, I'm a picky pizza eater, so I've been searching for a good local pizza place that isn't a chain. I was immediately impressed just through my phone call. The young man who took my order was incredibly polite, saying "yes ma'am" after my requests. My pizza and salads were ready for pick up 20 minutes later. Brought it home and dug right in. The salads were big for a "side" portion, with nice mozzarella cheese and fresh tomatoes. Then the pizza. Half cheese, half BBQ chicken club. SO GOOD. No gimmicks here. Just good dough, sauce, and toppings all around. The chicken pieces were especially great, as it seemed freshly cut into large pieces. I also lijed that the BBQ base wasn't too strong. Will definitely be back to get this again, as well as some other options.

Salad and sandwich were both delicious. Staff was friendly and prompt as is every time we visit this establishment

Wow. Yeah this is a super solid neighborhood pizza place. You want a pizza that isn't trying to be "the spicy guy" or the "sweet sauce guy" or the "super high-end toppings guy" or the "cracker-thin crust guy"? This is a GREAT middle-thick crust pizza with great sauce, great crust chew, great toppings. If I lived closer, I'd buy this pizza on a weekly basis. Go here, spend money, eat well.

Food outstanding Service Outstanding Ambiance outstanding. Overall outstanding. I would recommend it to everyone.

The pizza can be a hit or miss at times but overall good environment, friendly staff and overall good food! Pizza, wings & fries is all I can speak of. I choose this location over the others available if that helps!

The best pizza in the area. The sauce actually has flavor. There is no skimping on the toppings.

Update: from 5 stars to 1- and here's why: Simple mistake of incorrect order will result in another long wait to receive correct food. Made to feel like criminal/dishonest for calling, was told I would have to exchange food with delivery driver. Fine, but don't make out like I'm trying to get free food. Was told no refund on item (baked spaghetti), just the toppings they messed up (offered $3) or I could wait for another delivery (quoted 20 mins, took nearly an hour). Missed dinner with family. Owner Steve Krimmer was confrontational when asked about policy. Said "for every honest customer we have, we have as many dishonest ones." Well, that is a good attitude to have if you want to lose the honest ones by treating them like scammers. Just refund the mistake and move on (printed in b+w on house tix and receipt, manager should have checked order). Caused an unnecessary headache for all, and no accountability from Mr. Krimmer. I tipped driver well both times, as they do not receive additional $2-per-order delivery fee from delivering to fix kitchen mistakes (!). Will not be returning, and if you care about the average restaurant worker, or getting what you paid for, neither will you. Try Brooklyn Pizza & Pasta instead. ‐------------- PREVIOUS REVIEW: Absolutely love the spaghetti and meatballs!! Add a couple extra meatballs AND ask to add cheese before the bake. Chef's kiss!

I grew up on Krimmer's pizza (28 years ago) and it was always a favorite of mine. 10 years ago, a new relationship brought me back to the Deer Park area and I was still loving the Italianette! They haven't changed a bit. As life goes, I haven't had the Italianette in a good 5 years. Too long. I'm a basic cheese pizza kind of girl. After a trip back today with my kiddo, they are still absolutely killing the pizza game. Dare I say: Best Pizza On Planet Earth. I absolutely love a basic pizza sauce and they have it. Nothing loaded with sweetness or spices, just good old tomato sauce. The way their cheese caramelizes on top is just Heaven sent. AND the customer service is killer. The waiters were so kind to my kiddos and I and the lady at the counter where you pay was just a delight. It is wrong to expect a fancy pizza spot; this is just a small town, pizza done right joint! One of the few places I'd give 10 stars to if I could.

Out of all of the pizzerias this is by far the best pizza place I've been to. The service was nice and great for a nice chat. But the parking situation is not great. It is truly a hidden gem and I would recommend.

Continuing our supporting small businesses during COVID we couldn't not hit up Italianette Pizza as a Deer Park/Silverton staple! Huge fans of their pizza and hoagies, while you can find many other options on the menu as well. They even offer take and bake pizzas that our KY cousins love to pickup and cook at home! We enjoyed out fresh and hot items, after quick, clean pickup service.

Big Grip pizza!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! All I got to say! But I need more words to post this review!!

Best BBQ chicken pizza around in my opinion!! If you call ahead your order will be ready! If you don't call ahead you may have a wait. Ingredients are fresh and they don't skimp on the cheese!

Decided to nosh my way through the best hoagies and pizza joints, over the next 6-9 months, between downtown Cincinnati and up the East side into Loveland. The Italianette in Silverton was my first stop, and being about dead center between the two boundaries, seemed a good place to start. Great little pizza joint! Lots and lots of regulars at lunch, a real cozy and comfortable neighborhood eat-in spot. The servers were helpful and friendly so that was a good start. They checked in on me a few times and refilled my water without me asking, pretty attentive for sure. Pizza was, as others have noted, one of the best I've ever had (outside NYC & Jersey that is). I tried the 7-item Deluxe. Bacon topping are real cut strips of bacon laid on top, the spicy sausage, with fennel, really stands out. All of the ingredients seemed to be high quality. The steak hoagie was actually a letdown-- undercooked, short on pickles and onions, and just plain underwhelming on this first visit. Unfortunately it was mediocre and they need to really step up their steak hoagie game. That's why I'm giving 4 stars versus 5 here. I'll try it again sometime soon and if better, will update the review. They also have a buffalo chicken hoagie that sounds a bit different than most (and tantalizing), so I'll get that one as well to share with the wife (who very recently has become a hoagie aficionado herself!), and I'm sure she'll be a willing taster, as she too loved Krimmer's Italianette pizza.

Krimmer's Italianette Pizzeria (in Silverton/Deer Park), has one of the best pizzas I (and my family) have ever had. I placed my order by phone, (a large sausage and mushroom, with 2 steak hoagies), which was fast and easy. Getting to the restaurant and parking was a challenge, because the Italianette is does not have their own parking lot. They only have a few spaces out front, so be careful. The inside was clean and slightly cramped, but the kitchen crew were hard at work. The young woman behind the desk was friendly and made sure I had what I needed. When I arrived home, the pizza was still warm and fresh. The toppings were just right, the crust was not burnt, and it all tasted delicious. This pizza was definitely better than the Italianette in NCH. The hoagies were decent, but there was very little pizza sauce and a LOT of sliced onion. Again, not my favorite, but decent enough. I would HIGHLY recommend anyone who enjoys a good pizza pie to make their way to Krimmer's Italianette Pizzeria in Silverton/Deer Park. It is certainly worth the trip.

Pizza is amazing, family owned, absolutely a favorite here Must try, you won't go anywhere else

This is a quintessential mom and pop hang out. When my husband and I came for dinner after an evening of Christmas shopping, old, young and in between gathered over pizzas and hoagies watching basketball games playing from three different large-screen TVs throughout the dining room. Service was fast and friendly as we ordered a large, extra mushroom pizza, a steak hoagy and roast beef hoagy. Turned out the kitchen had run out of roast beef, so we doubled our hoagy order. The pizza had tons of cheese, almost as if it were extra cheese, and had just the right balance of chew, crispiness and garlic. For me, the steak hoagy was too bland due to the (flavorless) mushroom sauce I subbed for the usual pizza sauce it comes with. My husband loved his, which was the exact same type of steak hoagy with mushroom sauce. So who knows for taste! There's a lot to choose from on the menu of standard Italian favorites and some different dishes, taco pizza, BLT pizza. Also stationed at the front counter (not listed on the menu,) is a pretty large refrigerated dessert case with cheesecake, chocolate cakes and brownies for sale.

Been looking all over for a taco pizza and krimmers is by far the best place , actually I've yet to find any place that has taco pizza besides them , I love that they put the tomatoes and greens on the side makes it more efficient for those to add what they may or may not like or add as little or more of what they may like I also enjoy that they give you just the right amount of sour cream on the side as well , I've gotten the taco pizza twice from here first time was a family size which was huge second time I got a large , happy with the sizes and flavor highly recommended!

Ordered the meat lovers large pizza and bread sticks for carry out. The pizza was quite filling. Four grown men could not eat it all. As far as pizza goes it was above average but certainly doesn't fall into a "must have." The price however was definitely on point...we paid just $21. $21 to feed four guys is a bargain. The cheese sticks were some of the best I've ever had; warm, soft, and delicious. When I'm in the area and in need of some filling pizza I'll be back.

The place has great food but not the best service. The waitress with the pink hair was incredibly rude and not professional at all and made our group feel unwelcome. We all drove 30 minutes to dine in there just for the waitress to be extremely condescending and not answer our questions. We were all disappointed by the service as we love to dine in here. I will recommend eating here but not on a Thursday.

Consistently great pizza, subs and pasta. Good clean atmosphere and friendly staff. Good local joint.

I had heard nothing but good reviews about this place and decided to try it one for the first time one Friday night. I ordered the Deluxe Seven with no mushrooms since there were no substitutions allowed. Upon arrival I was asked to pay for the pizza, I asked to see it first. It looked nothing like the picture featured. it was scorched and the crust appeared over cooked. I requested that they remake the pizza. A man which I'm presuming to be either the owner or manager appeared with the pizza and stated that THERE WAS NOTHING WRONG WITH IT AND IF I DIDN'T LIKE IT, I COULD GO SOMEWHERE ELSE. I asked If he was telling a first time customer this and he stated most definitely, if I didn't like it, go somewhere else. So if you like RUDE MANAGERS/Owners that sell SCORCHED and OVERCOOKED PIZZA, this is the place for you. If you do not, remember don't complain or you may be TOLD NOT TO COME BACK AS WELL!!

Ordered pickup on Sun 7/31. Got home and order was wrong. Mgr was reluctant to come to the phone to discuss resolution. One of the worst customer service experiences ever, plus wings were very poor quality. Never again!

Holy moly, I was craving spaghetti and meatballs yet didn't want to spend $17+. Of course I also needed the meal to be high quality, this place is firing on all cylinders. Service was fantastic, large meal was cheap ($6.50 for spaghetti with two meatballs, Parm cheese, and garlic bread). The sauce and meatballs tasted house made and the service was excellent. An unassuming location but I'll be back soon!

Got a large pizza and order of wedge fries, service was fast and restaurant was clean.

After reading all the stellar reviews on Yelp and Chowdown Cinci, I decided to make a 30 minute drive to try this highly rated pizza place. Ordered a basic cheese pizza and steak hoagie. Figured this was an easy order and impossible to mess up.....but nope! It. was. Horrible! I'm not a picky person but man- how does this place get rave reviews? The crust- I swear- was frozen, tasted like a frozen Tombstone, no joke. Barely any sauce, which would have made it much better. Cheese was ok but not the gooey stringy kind you'd expect from a place that has such great reviews. The hoagie was even worse- just a hot hoagie roll with a fake meat patty. We could barely choke it down. I'm so sad it was terrible! I had such high expectations. I really am scratching my head as to how this place is so beloved.

Let me start with the positive: It is a cute little pizza shop and I would come back for the pizza again! The red sauce was wonderful and the pizza (medium/thick crust) was done well! Reasonably price and friendly service. The negative is that the ziti chicken alfredo with Fritz's secret recipe was fairly disappointing, sauce was thick but lacking cheese flavor. Chicken was cold, not much taste, poor execution overall... The learning / tips here is to stay with pizza and pizza only!!

The absolute BEST pizza and hoagies ever! The staff (all of them) are fantastic. The price is very reasonable. This is my family's favorite place to eat.

Just ordered a meat supreme, was delicious. Love their sauce and dough, adds to the finish product. Will be back to try other items.

This place was not bad in any way, nothing really stuck out as really good either tho. We went on a Saturday morning and the place was pretty empty. The interior of this place is very basic. Chairs and tables, a couple tvs, a few pieces of art on the wall. Just very basic. Every employee that we interacted with there were really nice and pleasant. Food came out fast and our waitress was about as good as you would want a waitress to be. The best thing that we ordered were the loaded fries. They were topped with mozzarella and cheddar cheese, as well as bacon, served with a side of ranch. These were about as good as you can get for loaded fries. I liked the mozzarella being used..it's kind of unique for loaded fries to be topped with this. The ranch was really good as well and complimented the fries quite nicely. I ordered a buffalo chicken sandwich, and we both ordered a small pizza with half cheese and half mild peppers. The sandwich wasn't awful but overall I just didn't like the taste of it. Might have had something to do with the buffalo sauce, it just didn't hit my tastes buds too nicely. The pizza wasn't bad but it wasn't really anything spectacular. The sauce was a bit acidic and a little heavy in parts. The pepperoni and mild peppers were good, they put a lot on which was nice. I will say the reheated leftover pizza that we had later on that night was surprisingly good. Not a fan of reheated pizza in general but this pizza actually held up pretty well. Overall, I would give this place another chance for sure. I would say I liked it and would eat it again, it just didn't stick out as anything special.

Great locally owned and operated pizza joint. I recommend the deluxe 7 pizza which includes full strips of bacon on it. Parking can be a challenge on Fridays and Saturdays though.

Get the breadsticks with cheese! Get them, get them, get them!!! I am not a pizza person, I normally get the buffalo chicken hoagie (also amazingly good), but their breadsticks with cheese are phenomenal.

Amazing calzones for a low price! Would definitely recommend! We ordered for pickup and the food was warm and freshly baked

Great food! The buffalo chicken is awesome. The staff is friendly. They get really busy on Friday nights but it's worth it. I took my kids here and both are picky eaters but they loved it.