Gina F.
Yelp
I had to take some time out of my day to return to my Yelp Elite roots and write an extensive glowing review for Ixchel. It been quite awhile since I've been to an establishment that has impressed me enough to jolt me out of my Yelp slumber to the keyboard, and Ixchel did just that.
Ixchel is Setauket's new best kept secret. In fact, it is easily the best restaurant in a 20 minute radius, comparable only perhaps to the excellence of neighboring Trattoria (Italian), and maybe St. James Iberico (Spanish) cuisine which are of similar caliber. So technically, it is easily one of the best restaurants proximal to Mount Sinai, Port Jefferson, Setauket, Stony Brook and Smithtown.
What makes this place so special? It's the hand of the owners, of course. We had the good fortune of walking in and being greeted by owner Daphnee Munar. In my opinion, she is the heart and soul of this place. You could tell how deeply she cares about executing authentic Mexican cuisine in the middle of Suffolk County, which is no easy feat. She seemed to have a real appreciation for quality ingredients and freshness, and is willing to go the extra mile (literally) to obtain more niche flavors to take her dishes to the next level. In particular, she has reportedly imported over 12 different species of fresh Chiles and an even larger number of dried chiles from Mexico in order to truly capture the essence of Mexican cuisine. In particular I overheard her mention Mayan influences and roots in Guadalajara.
Her attention to detail was simply unparalleled, and her homage honorable. Very few restauranteurs have the passion this woman does for producing unique, quality food paired with elegant attentive service. It is so refreshing in what is otherwise a cultural wasteland of an area. She is essentially carrying East Setauket on her back.
My husband and I have been to Mexico City a number of times and have been lucky enough to eat in some wonderful restaurants there. This restaurant is a few microchips short of a teleportation device, in the best way.
Furthermore, it seemed nearly everything is made in-house, from the syrups they use for their cocktails (which are AMAZING), to their desserts (I will be dreaming of her Tres Leches.) This is the additional time and effort and investment that take a restaurant from good, to excellence. You can taste the immense difference between something that is homemade and crafted with imported ingredients, and a concentrated syrup off the shelf at Whole Foods.
We visited Ixchel initially expecting to try out some cocktails and an app or two, and were completely swept away by a fresh, thoughtful and unique menu. What did we get?
-Tableside guac, made fresh in front of you with the ability to tailor some of the ingredients to your liking (ie, you could omit onion, or jalapeño if desired. For us, we love it all!)
- Tuna tostada
- Esquites
- Kanki Shrimp
Everything was truly delicious. Ixchel has a bright and busy future, and will likely soon require reservations exclusively due to popularity (She was kind enough to take us as walk-ins, we were unprepared!) I forgot to take photos because I was immersed in the trance-inducing deliciousness.
I read somewhere her goal was to have her patrons leave thinking about what they want to order for the next time they return, and to dream of coming back. Daphnee, you have done just that!
PS. Thanks for letting us try out the magical "worm salt"!!