Rok J.
Yelp
Bottom Line:
Extremely good pie & average sweet tea at reasonable prices. Kitschy interior decor & very friendly staff.
Top Line:
I stopped in to have a piece of their buttermilk pie $4.50'ish and a glass of sweet tea $2.25.
The tea was pretty average, being simply sweet without a lot of distinctly black tea flavor shining through. But at a couple of bucks for a usual large size drink glass, Jake's delivered on the price and value fronts.
Their buttermilk pie was an epiphany. The crust was very substantial: thick & hard to the fork. I feared it would be dry to the max. I was wrong. The crust was indeed dang sturdy. But there was so much butter in it that, at first bite, my mouth screamed, "Cookie!! This is a cookie!" It tasted like a homemade chocolate chip cookie without the chocolate. Exactly that flavor.
The custardish filling was equally tasty, being extremely rich and sweet. While you might expect a buttermilk pie to bring some tang from the buttermilk, such was not the case. There was simply sweetness floating out of the sturdy filling in drenching clouds of sugary goodness, with subtle shadings of vanilla. The texture changed with temperature: being a sturdy gelatinous creme when cold, that became more liquid plasma as it warmed toward room temperature.
The crusty top of the filling was also very noteworthy. It was like a coating of succulent little crumbles of creme brulee crust hanging tenuously onto each other to create a friable plating of toasted sugar begging for breaking. It was a delightfully crunchy texture contrast to the creaminess of the filling on which it floated.
And last, but certainly not least, a huge shout-out to the staff at Jake's for their high energy, super friendly hustle & care of their customers. While the line of diners waiting to be seated can get long, the staff keeps it moving at a quick clip given the number of people they are cycling through their establishment. My waitress was as friendly, courteous, and hospitable as you could ever want. Kudos to the staff for making us diners feel welcome.
I hope to hit up Jake's again before my sojourn in Waco is done.