Jamie's Ice Cream Co.

Tried the banana pudding and lemon poppy loaf and they were both very good. I don't like chocolate at all and won't order a traditional flavor from a shop, so I really appreciate when places have more unique flavors and ones that are fruity or herbal!

Wow, so impressed that such a small shop without even indoor sitting or enough outdoor sitting could be so popular! A little opening hours (kind of random) but the line was there and had to wait for our ice cream for little bit. But it was worth the wait and the money!!! Tried the milk dunked cookie and pistacchio. Oh they were good. Want to go again to try other flavors. Had that fresh milky aroma/taste to the ice cream. Also I could chew the pischaccio. Gave 4/5 just to be fair on the service and atmosphere part (not much of an 'atmosphere' cuz you are on the streets) but ice cream was really good! 👍👍

I tried 4 ice cream flavors here, and I wasn’t impressed by any of them. The cashier could work on making customers feel welcome. 2 stars for a cute store concept in a convenient location right in front of the T stop.

Ice cream here is fine but nothing special. The lemon poppy loaf is quite dense, especially with the chunks of loaf, so it almost feels like you're eating the bread itself. Flavor is decent. Pistachio is okay but the ice cream base is not as flavorful as I would like. The oat milk latte flavor is on the bitter side and I really like that one. Banana pudding is good, the flavor is not particularly strong, but I could throw it out the wafer. London fog was actually very good and the bergamot shone through. The texture of all the flavors was very creamy, but I'd say what it's lacking on is the intensity of the flavor. The baby scoop is only a little small to a single but almost half the price so get that.

Delicious ice cream variety! Mango, pistachio, chocolate and strawberry flavors were so good! I am sure the rest of the flavors are delicious as well! We went three times during our stay in Brookline.

Ice cream itself is good, but the service kinda sucks. There’s always a long wait regardless of how busy it is, and the scoop sizing is very inconsistent (based off multiple visits here). Today while waiting, my husband said he saw half of someone’s scoop fall onto the floor and then the teen working just give it to the customer as is… It would probably be better to just buy a pint from next door.

This was an amazing experience. Not only was the ice cream delectable, but the service was amazing as well. The servers really cared and ended up suggesting my new favorite flavor, banana pudding. I will most definitely be coming back!

Yummy ice cream, expensive, tiny portion…. The ice cream tastes good with fun flavors but expect to not get your money's worth portion-wise at all. My family was served “two scoops” where each of our scoops probably could only count as a 1/3 regular scoop. If I worked there, I’d be embarrassed to serve portion sizes like that, especially with the prices. It looked like each “scoop” was scraped from the bottom of the barrel and could be eaten with one bite.