Sam P.
Yelp
A friend of mine loves my reviews. I think she feels that I am a witty writer. Anyway, when I told her I was going to a steakhouse cause I missed ordering a good slab of meat, she was all onboard to join me.
Then I told her I was going to Jess & Jim's. She suddenly had other plans.....
My friend is a 30-something professional who will always choose ambiance over quality of food. This won't be a surprise to her (as she will be reading my review) so while I hoofed it to J&J alone, she definitely tagged along when I went to Capital Grille a week later.
Anyway, J&J attracts the over 55 crowd and the Young family with kids crowd looking for quality food over what type of wine is served or what type of lighting there is. Not only is it bare bones, it's shabby, even compared to some casual dining places I've been too.
That's not the point of this place. It's about the food here. So how was it?
I ordered a 12 ounce prime rib, with cottage fries and a side of green beans. It also comes with a salad appetizer. With a beer and tip, it came to about $69.
First, it doesn't matter how fancy the place looks or how expensive the prices are if the food isn't good. Especially the protein, which is the star of the show at a steakhouse.
The Prime Rib was very good, one of the better ones I've had in KC. It was more medium than medium-rare (the server admitted that it had been left out longer than it should have) but I barely noticed. The quality was great.
The cottage fries, was also good. They were cut in a haphazardly way, some looking more like pub chips than cottage fries, but they were cooked to near perfection.
The two disappointments were the salad and the green beans. The salad felt like it came from a bag, the one that is mostly iceberg lettuce and carrot shavings. It had exactly three grape tomatoes, two pieces of cucumber and I think a ring of red onion to make it look like a salad, but a failure.
And the green beans. They were only $3.50, but they definitely came out of a can. They were soggy, boiled and cut. Real green beans should be sauteed, whole and crunchy. These were complete crap.
Overall, it was a good place to eat (and let's face it, no one comes for the side salad and green beans) and if your scene is checking out senior couples and kids not on their best behavior, I guess this might be your place to go.