Miriam I.
Yelp
We tried Jim Brady's in Royal Oak for the first time in a very long time. We left feeling that we should have waited a bit longer. First, the ambiance: the setting was somewhat bar-like, with a wall of TVs - more than I remembered from previous visits. Next, the service. We were seated pretty much immediately, and our server was friendly and professional. He tried. Now, the food. 3 of the 4 in our party ordered the special, which was tenderloin tips served over pasta. Each couple ordered the beet salad, which was another special, and told our server we wanted to share the dishes. Here began the problems. Our server told us that the establishment "couldn't" divide the salad so we could share it. He did agree, upon our request, to bring 2 extra plates, and we then proceeded to divide each salad ourselves. Why they couldn't do this for us remained a mystery. Lucky for us, we were not forced to order 4 salads, as the quality was not so high. It was accompanied by what seemed to be a blend of 2 or 3 different dressings, which did not exactly mix completely, and which sat in a puddle on the plate. Not a great look. Next, the tenderloin over pasta. The meat was served in large chunks. This became problematic for 2 reasons: first, the cut of beef used was rather tough, and the knives we had to cut it with were dull - butter knives, actually. Once the meat was cut, 2 of the 3 diners saw that their beef was undercooked to the point of being raw in the center (the 3rd diner's meat was quite rare, but I managed to eat it). The 4th diner ordered the whitefish, which he found to be "adequate." After complaining about the raw beef to the server, and ultimately the manager, an offer was made to re-fire the dishes. When they came back, they were cooked, but just barely. The noodles accompanying the beef was what can only be described as a hodgepodge - 2 or 3 different types of noodles, assembled together for no apparent reason. The sauce was a bit strange as well. It was supposed to have mushrooms, but they were scarce to the point of being almost non-existent. In sum, we will most likely not be returning to Jim Brady's.