Bob A.
Yelp
There is a lot to like about this place and I'll totally be back. I came here with family and our food ranged from okay to excellent, mostly the latter. My uncle and and I ordered meatloaf and chicken piccata, respectively, and we both thought they were exceptionally generous with the portion sizes, particularly the meat, which was really tasty. We also split a couple of burrata salads for the table and those burratas were fantastic. We lingered after eating for a long time because it's a really comfortable, pleasant environment. We noticed other parties having a great time as well, and our server Eloise was knowlegable, fast, friendly, professional, and witty.
My aunt didn't like her penne with cheese & chicken much, and I don't think my mashed potatoes were cooked that well. Our desserts were okay but not great. The prices can be high, but we came in on a Sunday at dinnertime, and they have a happy hour dinner special that was a very good deal. They also have what I consider the ideal menu size; they have enough of a selection that there is plenty to choose from, but not so much that it seems like anything isn't well thought-out. The only other issue is that it's pretty noisy; the dining room was nowhere near full, but something about the acoustics of the room really amplifies the crowd noises. I'd give Jimmy's a four-and-a-half stars if I could, and I definitely recommend trying them out if the prices look okay to you. If you're on the fence in that area, come on a Sunday evening and try their happy hour options. If you like meat entrees that don't skimp, you'll probably be very satisfied!