JJs Casa Di Pizza

I'm from Idaho, here on a business trip, Staying at the Hilton Down Town and googled pizza near me. This place did not disappoint. The Wings were Scrumptious, the Pizza even better. The Staff was Great and answered all my meticulous questions about good food and beer in Buffalo NY. I would say a Must goto in this area.

We had a small deep dish pizza with pepperoni on one half and peppers and onions on the other. I dunked mine in ranch. It was sooooo good. I'm still thinking about that pizza. The server was quick and friendly and the place had a hometown vibe without making us feel like outsiders. The Pepsi and the water were both good. They have a jukebox in the dining area and sports on the TVs. I appreciated the signs "All y'all are welcome but you gotta act right" and LGBTQ Safe Space. ❤️ I would definitely go again. We managed to grab a parallel parking spot right out front, but there's also a paid parking lot less than a block away. The bathroom was functional and clean, nothing fancy.

The deep dish pizza is very nice. They have wide range of beer and drink selection. Service is nice too.

We found this place at random and could not be more surprised by how good it was. The waitress was so friendly and the food was outstanding. We had individual pizza slices (huge!), pasta, and subs. All of the sauces taste homemade and were a hit with my family. Highly recommend!!

Went with a group for lunch on a Friday and had no wait. Our server was friendly and attentive and the food came quickly. I had the chicken parm sub (1/2 size was plenty!) I upgraded to the garlic parm fries and OMG THEY WERE AMAZING! I’d come back here just for the fries!

Very tasty! Outstanding dough. This place has come along way, a beautiful outside patio, plenty of dining area, great draft and wine selection and amazing food!

Came here for dinner. Waitress was amazing. First time having deep dish pizza. Amazing. We also ordered the sweet baby rays whiskey sauce for our wings. A little heat with a little sweet.

You can’t go wrong with this place. They are always on point with their timing. The flavors are amazing in my opinion. This is cheese and pep with garlic bread crust. Staff is always friendly and welcoming. 10/10

Overall this place was good. I went on a Thursday around lunch time and it was very busy - so expect that, whether you're dining in or getting take out. The wait staff were just okay- she was not very friendly and was making us feel rushed. We also couldn't decide on the sauce for the fingers and her questioning made us feel like we should already know what we want. For the food I would rate it 4/5 overall. The pizza wasn't special, but it was good. The crust was flavorful. The fingers were the best item and the Cajun bbq sauce is something tasty to try! Also they charge extra for EVERYTHING Sauce on your fingers- extra Pepperoni on your pizza- extra Quite annoying....

Got stuck in the rain after leaving Zoo. We were wet and hungry. Only pizza and saucy wings could fix this situation. We weren't too far from downtown Buffalo, so Casa Di Pizza, we went !! They do have a pretty sizeable patio, but it was raining, so that was out of the picture. Their dining room was quite packed but still had seats available. They have full bar and also offer take out in the front of the restaurant. So we order their small family pack that comes with a large pizza w/one topping and 20 wings. We got cheese and pepperoni and 10 medium and 10 BBQ. I love their pizza !! The nice cup and charred pepperonis with beautiful cheese pull finished with a tangy sauce!! The wings were made just how I like them crispy yet saucy, nice, plump and juicy!! I also had Lemon flavored Deep Eddy Vodak and soda water with cherries and lemon bc I was feeling fancy,lol ! So if you are looking for some solid Buffalo pizza and wings in a chill atmosphere, oh yea they had tvs for game too,check out Casa Di Pizza !! They are also toddler approved as well, lol

Miss working downtown and eating here weekly, so door dashed to get my fix! The pizza is always solid. Sauce is so good, pizza always cooked to perfection. But my favorite is their subs. All the goombadi subs are just so good. For me, the best steak chicken or sausage subs in the area. Their stuffed peppers are really good, then throw that on some good seasoned meats, winner! Side note, their bar selection is good as well. $10.00 Pappy pours for my bourbon drinkers!

First time coming to this spot and was so glad I chose it. Nice bar area where I sat and ordered a pepperoni pizza while I had a blue moon. Mike behind the bar was very friendly and got me everything I needed once the delicious pizza came out. The pizza was perfect tasted like a pan pizza crust and had lots of cheese and crispy pepperoni which had a little kick to it. Overall really like the vibe and will definitely be back again soon!

Been here twice now for lunch and have loved it! They were not crowded and we got our food quickly. The first time I had their pepperoni pizza which was delicious! Then, I had their chicken fingers which again were great. Staff is very friendly and I will happily be back.

Been here numerous times and everytime the pizza was cut tavern style. This time it in triangles. The mozzarella to sauce ratio was not up to par and tasted gross.

The pizza and wings here are the best Buffalo has to offer. The roast beef on weck is in the top three I've ever had in Buffalo (and I've had many). No other place does wings so well, balancing crispiness without being overdone. The pizza uses quality cheese and pepperoni. Service has always been friendly and accommodating. Restaurant is small but is clean and updated inside. Parking is a challenge nearby but it's worth a small walk to get here.

Cute place, good service too. I'd come back to try other dishes. Bruschetta bread 10/10 Bread is just a simple sub roll. Soft inside and a slight crisp outside, perfectly toasted. The bruschetta was the perfect amount and cheese Pepperoni Pizza 8/10 Pizza was good. Nice and cheesy. Sauce was regular but had a slight sweetness, it was also very light. The pizza could have used more sauce. Wings - med - crispy 6/10 They were a little too crispy. So much so that the chicken was dry. The medium is more like a mild, no spice to it at all, and didn't coat them very well. The blue cheese is not the best either. Cheese ravioli 8/10 The kids said the marinara sauce on it was a little spicy for them. I didn't notice it much though. The cheese inside the raviolis was really soft and a good flavor too. French fries 8/10 Pretty good. Could use a few more seconds for some more crunch though.

Im staying in a nearby hotel and was looking for a decent pizza. I found it about a block away @ Casa di Pizza. I opted for the small deep dish and it was more than I could even think about polishing off. That just means I have dinner for the next night of my stay. The crust was about was expected and the sauce, cheese and toppings were all stacked on just right. One suggestion, and they will tell you as well, let it sit for five minutes once it's brought to the table. It'll still be screaming hot and letting it sit helps the toppings all connect with the crust. This is a cool location with the dining area in the back. The to-go counter is at the front. It was kept clean and tidy as folks were coming and going. There are at least 7 tv's going to keep you up on sporting events as well. Music is piped in with song choices being available by a digital jukebox. Definitely worth a try if in the area.

I stopped here many times for slices of pizza, when working downtown. They're all good but their best is their cheese and pepperoni. I recently had a whole steak and cheese sub and a stinger sub. Both were amazing! Great ambiance and service here too!

I just came to a fine realization. I'm from a city that knows nothing about Pizza. Best pizza ever! I tried their white pizza, phenomenal! I went for seconds and tried their pepperoni and cheese. Delicious!

Very laid-back and friendly ambience. Great service. And the food, this was the best pizza I have ever had. Very reasonably priced. Will definitely be back.

Had a pretty average experience with JJ's on a Friday night! Unfortunately, I don't know that this review is based on the full potential of their pizza. I preordered on the Slice app for a 6:30 PM pickup time. I got a notification at 5:30 that my order was ready. Neither me or my boyfriend were available to get it then (which is kinda why I preordered the food), so it was sitting there for a good hour before I was able to get it. We got an order of the spinach bread and a small brick oven-style pizza, half cheese, half mushroom. The food was cold, as you'd probably expect, but the taste was pretty decent! I really enjoyed the bread and the pizza was thin, which I enjoyed. One thing that was odd was that there was a LOT of what we think was cornstarch (to keep the pizza from sticking to the tray while cooking) on the bottom of the pizza. Like a lot a lot. It was all over our table and our clothes by the time we were done eating. I might try here again in the future, but I was kinda bummed that I spent $30 for food that wasn't even warm. If you do order through the Slice app (or any food delivery/pickup app), I would suggest ordering soon before you want to eat rather than preordering!

I love the location. Here I am on a nice June day sitting in a great patio with a great breeze facing the public library in the hotel Lafayette. Yeah ambiance is above average for sure. Had a couple of drinks and the large pizza special which is $19 on Monday and Wednesdays. The pizza is fantastic a slightly sweet sauce beautifully dressed with nice quality cheese and a nice quality char pepperoni. Lovely fluffy crust. Such a fun experience.

Picked up a take out order , it was speedy service with a smile. I ordered the garlic parmesan fries ,they were crispy but I expected more garlic and cheese.I also got my hot, tasty, delicious veggie pizza.It includes spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, onions, green peppers,tomatoes, mozzarella cheese in a tomato sauce base.They also have hot and cold subs, salads, wings and chicken fingers.

Placed a to go order with friendly staff.I ordered the garlic parmesan fries, they were crispy but a little bland.Also had the veggie pizza which was a tomato sauce base, spinach ,broccoli, muchroom,onions,green pepper, tomatoes and topped with Mozzarella cheese ,it was hot and tasty. They also offer wings,fingers ,hot and cold subs and salads.

We enjoyed take out after the bar exam. We chose the brick oven pizza with sesame crust. There were lots of great options for toppings. We also had a salad, which I loved because it had a ton of olives! The food was ready when they said it would be. It was easy to park on the same block.

Very good food, pizza and wings are amazing. Very friendly staff clean restaurant and great location.

This review and stars is not about the food. The deep dish pizza we had was really good. The issue was the server. My friend and I went yesterday 12/19 at 11:30. We were looking to try a deep dish pizza and decided on Casa Di Pizza. The menu price is $15.99 for a cheese deep dish pizza. We added pepperoni. We both had waters to drink. So you would figure it was pretty simple to figure out. Our waitress dropped off the bill. The bill read ( I may be a few cents off) $25.63. The bill said something like $21.00 for cheese pizza and $2.49 for pepperoni. I brought this to the attention of our server who blamed it on the pricing in the register. So , She change it. She then brought back a new bill for $23.26ish. The price of the pizza with pepperoni was now $22.00 roughly. Knowing pepperoni is $2.49 going of the last itemized bill. The pizza was still overcharged by $3-$4 . I told my friend I am not going to say anything and just pay it. I'm fine with it. Sometimes it is just easier to pay and get out. My friend left $6 for the tip. So , I gave her a $50 for the bill of $23.26. I joked with my friend that I better count the change. My change came back, She gave me $25 even. So she shorted me $1.74. I am not sure if she thought we would not notice. At this point it has me wondering if she was trying to pocket money all 3 "mistakes". I did not mention anything about incorrect change. I unfortunately just grabbed $3 from the tip. I am not happy that I did that and feel bad for it. But something was definitely up with this. I would go back for the food. If you do go there. Please keep this in mind and double check your receipt with the prices. It was not close even after I brought it up.

Deep dish isn't it. No flavor and the crust was just too much. Not deep dish plz. Feels like ur biting into concrete

Good price, fast pleasant service and huge pieces of pizza! I would recommend this restaurant.

This place is a stones throw away from my office, so I think I'll be going there every once in while for lunch . The menu is vast compared to most pizzerias , lots of pizzas, subs, appetizers , chicken wings, chicken fingers, wraps , salads, pasta, and even chicken/rib combos . The prices are slightly higher than other pizzerias but not so much for me to avoid enjoying a good meal. On this particular Wednesday, I opted for a full Penne Parmesan. It came to about $14.50 plus tax. And it was huge ! Not quite as delicious as Chefs (in my opinion) but pretty tasty , the penne was a perfect al dente. It came with a side salad (prefer shredded carrot and cheese to the olive/onion toppings but I just picked them off !) and a roll. All in all , this meal will feed me for 3 lunches! A staple on the 500 block of Main Street, so place your order ahead of time!

Why weren't you opened on Sun. April 7th??? Sign said that should have been! We are expats wanting to enjoy our favorite pizza and wings while watching basketball playoffs!

5 minute walk from work and a call ahead order and reserved table. Couldn't ask for a better to have lunch with my co-workers. We only get an hour for lunch so we called ahead to place our order. As we sat down, they took our drink order and BOOM, our pizza appeared. First time here and pizza was delicious. Burnt pepperoni just the way I like it. In the summer they also have a patio so you can eat outside and enjoy the weather. Great place with great service!

I stopped in with a colleague for lunch today. The staff were friendly and the restaurant was clean, but the prices were crazy. I know inflation is causing things to go up but it's hard to justify $15 for two regular slices and 2 drinks during lunch time when none of the other places charge as much. You typically see a lunch special with 2 slices and a drink for $5 to $7. The pizza was ok - a little sweet for my taste but still tasty.

Got a recommendation from our hotel valet to try this place. The pizza was delicious, nice atmosphere, friendly employees.

Visiting from out of town and was mortified and traumatized to find a huge dead bug at the bottom of my salad that I was eating. The fact that it wasn't noticed during preparation.........,such a traumatizing experience. Terrible!!!

Waitress was great. Food was tasty. Drinks were strong! Will try a deep dish pizza next time.

We stopped in here with a couple hours to go before a play at sheas. Place was not packed. Maybe 1/2 full. It took forever to get a drink. One of our Guinness's showed up as 90% foam? Seriously. And nothing was done about this. Waitress said she doesn't pour the beer? No refills were offered the entire time was sat there waiting for food. People who arrived after us received pizzas. We were told our food (all sandwiches) was on its way and 20 minutes later still no food. We had to leave without finding out if the restaurant was any good, thirsty, and with empty stomachs. Thankfully Sheas has giant chocolate chip cookies or we'd have starved. Not a promising experience.

Had a Philly steak sub with fries. Very, very disappointing. Fries soggy and cold...must have been sitting in the basket for a while before plating. Sub was seriously disappointing!!! Chopped up so fine it looked like they put it in the blender. Barely any cheese and a few small pieces of peppers but no sight of any onions or mushrooms. I was extremely happy that I only ordered a half sub and didn't have to take another half home. Was a very tasteless meal. Will not return. I must say service was very good and she was tipped well.

Super cute spot!! We stumbled here by chance and it's absolutely going to be a spot in the near future again!! Bartender was super nice !!!

I happened upon the new location and wondered if the food was still as good as it was on Elmwood. It is! Wonderful service. My sub was perfect and satisfying.

They had gotten better. I love the Sauce. The Hyatt orders from them alot for all of their Pizza Parties.

Eating a slice of their pizza brought back memories of the Elmwood of yonder years. Memories of my nearby Catholic high school, leg-warmers, poofy hairdos, ripped off the shoulder t-shirts.... "oh what a feelin'"... where did that Jennifer go anyway? If you don't know the reference, or think I'm talking about J.LO (the current flesh-dancing Jennifer), you either got the wrong girl, or the wrong era or are just too young to know. Good for you if it's the later of the three! So sad of me-- I'm that old!! Sad that this great pizzeria moved from its old home on Elmwood. But as a bit into this heavenly, saucy, cheesy, but still crusty-dough, Buffalo-style pizza yesterday, I knew the quintessential Casa di Pizza is still very much alive and well! What a pleasant surprise. It's a top contender in the best pizzeria in buffalo contest after many decades, in my opinion. Now, I don't frequently visit the area of its new location. But when I do, I know where I'm going for a slice. Oh yeah!

The new location is pretty cool. I appreciate that they have the regular pizza parlor style in the front, and the restaurant/bar style in the back. I sat at the bar and their drinks are reasonably priced. Grabbed a slice of pizza and it was just as I remembered. The location is a nice size. It can get s little loud and I felt bad for the bartenders because they looked like they were EVERYWHERE! Overall not a bad experience. They use paper straws which is always interesting. One thing that annoyed me was my internet did not work in there. I had cell phone service but couldn't get online. It was strange. I will probably be back again. I hear they have a spinach artichoke dip that's really good.

Casa is a well oiled machine. Order online easily, and they bring it right out to the curb when you get there. You can choose a special crust for no extra charge on your pies. Highly recommend for pandemic takeout.

Have been here twice and I Love their slices. They have a lot of different menu options and I would definitely like to try more options in the future.

Loud... well, that's a good thing, they are busy and the food is moving through the kitchen Don't bother with the wings, I guess they're required to be on the menue. I had the antipasto salad. Fantastic! A salad built for two...or three. Very good. Wife had the chicken parm. Pretty average, but says the sauce was very good. Service was very good as well.

I've been wanting to try out the new location because this was always my favorite pizza place. I was hesitant because it's been years and I thought there is no way it's still going to be as good and I'm so glad I was wrong! It wasn't very busy at lunch time for dining in so our server was really attentive even though she had tables inside too. There was a nice patio to sit outside on a beautiful day and watch everyone walking by(the bees were a tad annoying). There was street parking (metered) right across the restaurant so it was convenient or it's right at main so you could even take the train there.

If you want a raw, cheese pizza, this is your place! Also, one of the boneless wings was raw. Not sure if this is their style of "cooking" but I will never eat here again.

Hmmmm ok sub, I feel the sub should've looked and tasted better than it did. If I was younger the sub would've been great, especially after a few cocktails. But now that I am older, I prefer Costanzo's subs way better.

Maybe I went on a bad day, but I wasn't impressed by the service nor the food. The workers weren't very friendly and the guy who took my order sort of made me feel bad for ordering in general. I got wings and he put a note that I wanted them extra well done, which I didn't ask for. He also forgot to put in an order of fries. The wings were so dry and burnt. I couldn't finish them even though I absolutely love wings. The fries came out soggy. I'm not sure if I'll give this place another try, but again I'm really hoping today wasn't a reflection of their business.

Casa Di Pizza offered nurses at Roswell a free deep dish heart shaped pizza - which was decided to try out the other night. Having deep dish pizza was a nice change from just traditional pizza! The dough was really soft and I really liked the crust. We also got an order of barbecue wings which I liked, but I wish the sauce was a little thicker! Cute restaurant inside. On street parking.

The Casa Di Pisa is a house in a small city in Italy famous for a building that looks like it's falling over. Whereas the Casa Di Pita is a Greek place. And the Casa Di Pina Colada is a bar specializing in girlie cocktails (my fave kind). Whereas the Cashier Di Pizza is the cute guy who rang me up for my slices the most recent time I came in here. What to get: Late Night Slices. This is the new location of the pizza legend that used to be on Elmwood. Their slices are still really wet, delicious, yummy, and typical Buffalonian, however their prices have gone way up, so I understand all of the negative reviews. However I review based on price alone, and their products are still yummy-as-f*** (YAF to hipsters). If "Consistent" was the name of a band, then this pizza place would be the lead singer. In the sense that it is "In Consistent." Seriously though, the first time I came here (a couple of months back), I got two slices and they were the biggest, hottest, wettest, juiciest, sexiest slices of Buffalo Pizza I can remember eating. Then the second time I came here the slices were lukewarm and dry and smaller and definitely not a 5-star experience. The third time, the experience was somewhere between the two... so I have no idea what the norm is. I guess a fourth visit is on the proverbial cards. The Casa Di Priya is the house of my cute Hindu ex-girlfriend. Actually it's her Dad's house and if he had ever found me in there with her, well... I wouldn't be writing this review today. Names have been changed to protect the guilty. So I'm not sure exactly what to tell you about CDP. They make quintessential, doughy, wet, juicy, cheesy, saucy Buffalo-style pizza and they make it very well - sometimes. If you go on a day when the slices are akin to my first visit, then you're in luck. They're not too pricy for a place near downtown ($2.50 tax included), and they're juicy and will fill you up. On the other hand I can't guarantee you that you'll get amazing slices, since once they were just good and once they were, well, bad. The Casa Di Peter is where Mr. Sellers, Mr. Gabriel, Mr. Parker aka Spiderman, and Mr. North (the one who erupts like a fountain, famously so... OK this is awkward. My friend told me about it), all share a room. Apparently, in that household at least, Mr. Gabriel is, in fact, not the "Sledgehammer" as previously advertised. That mantra is owned by one of the other three residents and I shall say no more. In addition to the on-again-off-again slices, I have tried the dirt cheap Chicken Finger Sub (when it was on special... a full size sub for $5), and it was... well, dirt cheap. It wasn't the best CFS I've had, but then again it was far from the worst. Pretty average really. Not too much chicken on there, but you can't expect too much for $5. My friend who loves CFS sandwiches said that it was delicious. But then she says that about nearly everything. The Casa Di Lolita is not worth visiting. You might think you're having fun, but being in jail is no fun. Take it from my friends Bubba The Lifer and Large Marge. Actually that's my sister and brother. :( Finally, the great thing about CDP is that it's open super late. I think it's something like 11.30 or 12, which means that when most places are done for the night, you can get big, cheap, hot slices here to fill you right up. If you miss the window and CDP has closed, then venture over to Hertel Avenue where Zip's (yum!) and Daddio's (decent with much better service than Zip's) await and are open until 2 or 3am. And of course, let's not forget that the Casa Di Panochita is where you go in Mexico as the equivalent to the Casa Di Lolita aforementioned. But again, I have to strongly advise against this. It's just unethical. Then again so are most of my reviews.

DO NOT. I. Repeat do not get the fish fry! It's garbage. It's not beer battered it's crap out if the freezer. Having said that. It comes with decent sides, heavy on the onion which I don't mind but others might. The calzone is delish! Sauce is also garbage like stuff out of a can. However, the dough is really tasty! Lots of cheese obviously. I got ham, green olives and mushrooms and it was soooo good!! Haven't had the julienne salad yet as I'm stuffed but it looks solid. Please update your door dash. I asked for extra items in the comments and to charge me as the site doesn't allow to select several items. You did not acknowledge my requests. Not ok. I'd probably give a 2.5 if I could. That calzone was killer! The door dash guy was also lousy. Left my food on my neighbors steps and didn't call to tell me it was there

Got a Stromboli for take out and it was delicious! You may open the box and think that is small but boy will you be wrong. It is packed with so much cheese pepperoni and green olives. The crust was so crispy and peppered with Parmesan cheese on top. You will be fighting to finish it because you are so full but it is so tasty that you can't stop. The price is a bit high but worth it for the deliciousness. I will be ordering more Stromboli in the near future.

Stopped in JJ's Casa Di Pizza, after a recommendation from, two different people, for lunch during a quick trip to Buffalo. At first, I didn't think about stopping in because it was a 'Pizza' joint. I'm so glad I did, they had a dining room and bar area too. I had an amazing Prime Rib Sandwich and side of Garlic Parmesan Fries and topped off with great service from Emma.

Civic Duty has brought me to downtown Buffalo for the last few weeks. Iv gone into Casa a couple times now looking for a delicious slice. Unfortunately, all I was given was a rubbery cold slice both times. I tried really hard to like this place as most people I know in Buffalo LOVE it. For what it's worth, I won't be coming back to try a third time.

I'll admit I'm bias as I have friends who work here but I've made many more just coming to visit those people because the owners and staff are just so friendly and wonderful. The bar/dining room is a pleasant setting along with their outdoor patio. There's an expansive menu with lots of great choices. The Goombadi anything is always a win. Their salads are huge. And my favorite item that gets often overlooked is the Lemon Pepper Eggplant wrap. Shookies soups are always killer! Even if you're a stranger, you'll be a friend here in no time.