Joe's Pizzeria (Lynbrook NY)

I stopped in here to get a slice while I was working and I have to say it is probably the worst slice I have had since middle school lunch, there is not a single redeeming quality about this pizza. The sauce is bad. The cheese is bad. The crust is bad. It stretched so thin, You can't even hold it. As somebody who used to work in a pizzeria, I can legitimately say this is embarrassing to serve to people

When I arrived, it took a little while before someone came to the counter to take my order, but honestly, it would be nit-picking to make that into an issue. Once my order was taken, I had a clean place to sit down and eat my food. The price is fair, and the pizza was good. That's important! Overall, it was a good experience. Will return again.

I pray I never have to come back to this place. The greasy pizza on a preclean plate that I was actively angry that I was eating it. The guy at the register cared more about ogling the high school aged girls than about giving me good pizza.

We live overseas but are staying with my mom in Malverne, Popped into Joe’s pizza to grab a much needed NY pie. The pizza with meatballs was delicious as were the wings and garlic knots. The young gentleman behind the counter did the nicest thing though. As we were waiting I commented to my daughter how much I used to love zeppoles. He handed me our order and we left, when I got home to my surprise there was a bag a zeppoles. Thank you!

I'm from Queens and know about good Pizza....And this will not disappoint! First time ordering today, My wife Lisa went to pick it up and she came out and had nothing but good things to say about it! The pizza, The wings and garlic knots ..Speechless ! I will be ordering from here on the regular! Please don't change anything you guys did today!

The best eggplant pizza you can get. But for the real experience go next door to their restaurant. It's heaven, great atmosphere, service, food. Everything you need is there. It's like going home for a big family meal. If I could give 10 stars I would.

If I could give it 0 stars I would! I walk in, guy behind the counter has an attitude as soon as he sees me. I ask for 2 slices of pizza. Guy: anything else? Me: yes a can of soda Guy: which one Me: ok let me see As I’m looking to tell him which I want, he’s looking toward the window and says “Today!” (Blank stare out the window) Me: excuse me what did you just say? Guy: with a smirk “what do you want” Me: No, I’m not getting anything from you. And I walk out. He’s lucky I didn’t curse him out in front of his 1 other customers. I’m sorry you don’t treat others this way. I will never go in there again. I ended up going to REGINAS PIZZERIA instead, great customer service, friendly, and their pizza is delicious.

We just moved in down the block and I passed by a couple of days ago and it smelled so good! We ordered last night and the wings and the pizza were awesome. Service was great too! Thanks so much! Can't wait to get another pie soon!