John
Google
I'm really impressed with this place and I don't give 5 star reviews easily, but Jolene's really earned it. Right now it still seems under the radar, but comparing favorably to Andiario in presentation, freshness, and execution, I don't expect it to stay hidden for very long. Do not let fear of mispronouncing a French word or a misplaced perception of pretentiousness dissuade you from trying Jolene's - it's amazing, and worth going outside your comfort zone for. And while I'll say it's not cheap, it is accurately priced. And it stands confidently among the very best restaurants in the Philly suburbs.
Food: I was wowed by nearly everything brought out in three dinner courses (and some of my wife's food too), and a couple dishes were just good. All of the dishes had a laser focus on detail which came through in both taste and presentation - just lots of little things done right. For 3 examples: 1) A twist on Vichyssoise, with the cold soup poured over an accent of a delightful crumble medley. 2) Fresh scallops seared separately from the rest of the Bouillabaisse to achieve the right temperature and texture, then added in at plating. 3) steak tartare with the texture and freshness of Tuna sashimi, so perfectly spiced that it tasted cooked, sitting among the best beef experiences I've had in a long time. Wines by the glass were French only and presented 16 well selected and fairly priced choices. I had no trouble pairing my wines to each course with some baseline knowledge of French wine, and got to try a few things new to me.
Service: Grest restaurant service should feel simultaneously intimate and anonymous while providing guidance and reassurance. Our server Nick nailed it and was an excellent guide. He is clearly passionate about his work and is well informed, but also smart enough to shift gears and stand back to let the food and wine do the talking. He was ever present when needed and blended into the wallpaper when not, but was never far - threading this needle is difficult for many servers to pull off but it separates the best from the rest. And this is not to diminish the rest of the staff who worked hand in glove as a team, not missing any details, and coming together to make Jolene's a memorable experience.
Setting: They've done such a great job attending to lots of little details comparing favorably to Parc in Philly or Mon Ami Gabi in Las Vegas. The visual style threads the needle well between old and new, respecting both the place it's located and the fresh menu. As the bar and dining room filled up it did not get excessively noisy, and hushed conversation was still possible. Being able to see the bar but not be in the bar added visual interest. Even the bathrooms were intentional - accessible through one pink mystery door in the back of the bar, revealing a well composed unisex bathroom lobby and full privacy rooms.
In short, I'm coming back. Hopefully for many years to come. I had high expectations and they were exceeded. There's enough in this current menu to keep coming back, and when the newness wears off I would encourage them to consider offering or converting to a prix fixe menu once people understand what Jolene's is about. For a completely different experience I want to come back on a cold day to sit at the bar with the onion soup and a beer. They will probably tempt me into staying and spending more than I intended, but it will be ok. My only regret will be I'm not getting the full sit down service.
To wrap I'll quote a famous chef who says that perfection is lots of little things done right. While Jolene's isn't quite perfect yet, it's close enough, and they are surely on that road.
Food - 5/5
Service - 5/5
Ambiance - 4.5/5
Comfort - 4/5
Value - 5/5