Mike S.
Yelp
I sort of can't decide on 2 or 3 stars, but a proper 3 is generous. Read the review and decide for yourself.
Service here leaves much to be desired - for one, you better KNOW what you want, and you better order it loudly and clearly enough for everyone to hear, at a crowded counter. The person who took your order will shoo you away with a number card. The cashier will call your number to pay for your order, upon which you'll stand awkwardly while you pay in the one point of egress for the entire staff between the counter and the kitchen. But, don't give her the number card. She'll call you up again once your food is ready.
(There are no signs or indicators how this all functions by the way, I learned this through trial and error.)
Once your food is ready, hand over your number card and GTFO ASAP.
The place is very small, servicing to go orders only. I guess you could call ahead, which is probably the smarter thing to do. The location means morning commuters are grabbing their bagels and coffees, so be mindful of your timing if you're someone who doesn't like crowds.
The food itself? I see a lot of reviews saying "best bagels in Hoboken" - which tells me Hoboken has the same issue that Jersey City has - the places that make the best bagels can't afford to stay in business due to the rising costs of rent and supplies. Small businesses are pushed out in favor of major chains and franchises, leaving whatever/whoever is left that can afford to remain. With no other competition, JP's - much like Wonder Bagel in JC - is "the only game in town." Their bagels aren't going to greet you with a culinary experience, but they're better than the corporate options.
Lunch options are better, IMO. If a bit pricy, their sandwiches are pretty standard deli fare.
All in all, I want to support them and they aren't necessarily BAD - but they could definitely get some easy improvement wins by streamlining the chaos of ordering, paying, and receiving your food.