Juicy Lucy BBQ
Permanently Closed

Juicy Lucy BBQ

Permanently Closed

Texas-style BBQ, giant portions, brisket, pastrami, mac

best bbq
coleslaw
texas-style barbecue
friendly service
moist turkey
ribs fall off bone
waffle fries
catering
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null
Juicy Lucy BBQ by null

Information

20 Jefferson Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10312 Get directions

$10–20

See Menu
Restroom
Comfort food
Debit card accepted
Contactless accepted
Lunch

Information

Static Map

20 Jefferson Blvd, Staten Island, NY 10312 Get directions

+1 718 317 7427
juicylucybbq.com
@juicylucybbq

$10–20 · Menu

Features

•Restroom
•Comfort food
•Debit card accepted
•Contactless accepted
•Lunch
•Dinner
•Catering
•Dessert

Last updated

Jan 13, 2026

Powered By

You might also like

Terms of Use • Privacy Policy • Cookie Policy
 © 2026 Postcard Technologies, Inc.
@eater
391,688 Postcards · 10,992 Cities

NYC Restaurant Closings, December 2023 - Eater NY

"Texas-style barbecue joint that had locations in Ocean Breeze and Eltingville. The last remaining location in Annadale closed due to declining sales, rising supply costs, and loss of key staff." - Luke Fortney

https://ny.eater.com/2023/12/1/23969271/nyc-restaurant-closings-december-2023
Juicy Lucy BBQ

E

Google
GIANT portions of amazing bbq. The service is super quick and the place is spotless. The brisket, pastrami, and chicken sandwiches are SO GOOD. Have to get the waffle fries or mac and cheese too! We have been here a few times and each time the food is on point. Definitely worth the money.

Anthony G.

Google
Incredible experience starting with Angela! She is very friendly, accommodating, and kind. The food is unbelievable, better than the brisket places I’ve had in North and South Carolina. Everything is flavorful and moist. Huge quantity of food, you cannot go wrong!! 10/10

Lisa N

Google
Awesome, fast and friendly service. Clean environment. Food was amazing and surprisingly large servings. They do charge a fee if you use a credit card, but it was definitely worth it!

Keith C.

Google
This is the absolute best place for bbq The brisket is top notch along with the pastrami Pastrami is better than the deli They also have some of the best Cole slaw I ever had

christine j. M.

Google
Such an amazing experience and incredible food. Just catered a 40 person party and they went out of their way to make everything perfect. Angela at store was so insightful about how to present food and the owner Rob called me while on vacation just to walk me through every detail. The delivery driver was extremely courteous. Best experience ever. Brisket to die for!! Fried chicken thighs were all the rave.

Matt F.

Google
Juicy Lucy is by far the best BBQ I've ever had. The depth of flavor in the brisket and pulled pork is unbelievable. Not to mention the owner is amazing and goes to the ends of the earth to ensure customers have a great experience. Will never get my BBQ anywhere else.

katrina M.

Google
I normally do not leave reviews but I had to with this one. It’s not worth the money unless you are looking to pay outrageous prices for a few pieces of meat and a mini bag of fries. For what they are charging for brisket at least throw in Cole slaw and maybe bread or don’t be skimpy with the fries. But if you are going charge $20 for 5 pieces of brisket at least live up to your title of best brisket title , just tasted greasy no flavoring at all. My first experience eating there was just as bad as my second experience and I will not order from here again. At least when the restaurant was open the food was good and worth every penny, this place is just horrendous.

Rosemary D.

Google
I love their BBQ the smoked Turkey is so moist, and the Ribs fall off the bone tender both are so good. Best mac and cheese and fries. My favorite is the cookout you get a taste of everything so much food and worth every penny.