Paul L.
Yelp
This is one of those rare occasions on which I get to celebrate my friend Brian's birthday in person. So he gets to pick the venue, since he knows the local scene in Vail/Beaver Creek a heck of lot better than the other two ski bachelors (all 3 wives were unable, or unwilling, to come). Brian had said that he picked a place that's "not expensive" since I had proposed to Ned that we treat him - I think that might be by Vail standards :-)
We were seated promptly in a dim, rustic dining room that ended being 75% full - not bad for a Monday. Cocktails run around $13 while wines vary (seems to be a pretty good wine list). I chose the sea bass and some Dryland SB to wash it down with ($11 a glass is an OK price for a place like that I guess. We shared a PEI mussels app ($18) - a first for Brian, and he liked it! The mussels tasted really good, but seemed to be a little small for "1 lb". My sea bass ($42) was absolutely delicious, but on the small side (5-6 oz.) - I was eyeing jealously at Ned's black cod, which must have been 9-10 oz. See I had chosen the sea bass because, at a difference of $2, who wouldn't? Well had I known there's a size difference too, I believe I would have reconsidered - skiing makes you hungry, you know! Brian chose the elk ($38), which he pronounced delish and devoured.
This is clearly a well-run kitchen with a skilled chef. So why 'only' 4 stars? Several small factors, all of which add up. As mentioned, more than the price level, it was the lack of transparency in the 2 fish dishes. We'd told our waitress that it was Brian's b-day, and when we came around to ask what dessert he wanted, we all thought it'd be comp'd. Call it mis-communication, I guess (she even charged the extra $3.50 for the ice cream that she recommended to be added to the toffee cake!) If the occasion arises, we would return. I'll just be smarter then!