Laura C.
Yelp
1.26.22: From the Picky AF Princess of Bakeries! I review yet another b/c I have an insatiable sweet tooth and I grew up in a family of bakers. My great grandmother owned her own bakery in NYC, so we were weaned on eating and baking good stuff!
First off, this place is outta control on how many items are offered. Holy cannoli! (No cannoli but that's prob ONLY thing they don't have)
Their staff was superb in answering my many questions, looking up ingredients and names. I learned that these adorable little star cookies are called "zimsterne." They're traditional German cookies made with almond flour & cinnamon, so cute little Gluten Free spice cookies.
I love their cakes b/c they're stunningly simple in design but exquisitely unusual with flavors. Need to order one to actually taste!
*Cakes: Dulce de Leche, Chocolate Parisian, Pink Champagne, Strawberry Diplomat Cake & more
*Cookies: Florentines, Linzer Tarts, Sugar Cookies (w/ irreverent Valentine messages), Zimsterne (German Cinnamon Stars) & more
*Danish: Cheese, Lemon Ricotta, Bavarian Cream Strawberry Compote & more
*Donuts: Cake, Glazed & Raised (made with yeast!), & more
*Muffins: Blueberry, Raspberry, & more
*Pastries: Gator Bars, Strudel & more
They sold me on the Bavarian Cream Strawberry Compote Danish:
flakey buttery pastry, phenomenal filling combo of fruit w/ light cream = party in my mouth!
I asked if they had Kringle (a pastry from Wisconsin) & they didn't as it tends to be carried around Christmas. But they told me about the Gator Bar, layers of pastry, with a thin spread of caramel in between, topped off by pecans. I bought one of the half priced bars (b/c they sell items cheaper after a few days) - it was kind of dry, still flavorful but not "all that." Wish i'd just sprung for a full price Gator!
Karl's was giving away one free donut to customers who bought a regular priced item - donuts that were misshapen but nothing wrong with the taste. I'm not usually a donut fan but my cake donut w/ chocolate glaze & peanut topping was delish & I devoured it in minutes, so no pic.
I left with one Danish, one Gator Bar & my free Donut. Stoked for all this deliciousness & can't wait to order one of their cakes for upcoming event!