Katie's Cookie Jar

Beautiful unique decorations AND great tasting cake and icing?! You can’t go wrong here. Special orders far exceed expectations, and pick up some fresh donuts when your order is ready! Very reasonable pricing for the amount of work I’m sure is required for these cakes. Will continue to use Katie’s!

I ordered cookies for the Pittsburgh cookie table at my wedding. It was absolutely amazing and exceeded all our expectations! The variety of cookies she offered was wonderful and were delicious. Our guests couldn’t stop talking about them and kept going back for more. She was such a pleasure to work with and incredibly accommodating, which made planning feel easy and stress-free. We are so grateful for everything she did and we couldn’t recommend her bakery enough!

I order from Katie's Cookie Jar regularly. My family gets donuts almost every weekend. The pepperoni rolls are amazing, and they have regular plus a pepper jack one that is perfect if you want a little kick. She has made beautiful birthday cakes/cupcakes for my family that not only look amazing, but taste amazing! Everyone is always asking for more. The cookies are so unique and she is so talented as an artist and baker. You won't be disappointed!

I absolutely love ordering from here. Everything is always beautifully decorated and delicious.

I custom ordered donuts to look like life preservers for a special occasion and they were perfect! The donuts were so soft and fresh and the icing was delicious. I highly recommend and will definitely be ordering from here again.

Get cookies for your party from here! Although the cupcakes were delicious, everyone raved over the cookies at my daughters first birthday. Not only were they adorable, everyone commented on how delicious the cookie tasted. They were such a hit, that I did not even get a chance to try one before everyone scooped them up.

Great place for all your goodies. The shop was extremely clean and everything was in order. The lady that put my order together was super duper nice! My wife sent me with a list but wasn't specific on certain things so I had to text her to find out what exactly she wanted. Most people would probably get annoyed waiting on me to double check on what my wife wanted but this lady was Awesome. She never got upset and just kept carrying on a conversation even after we got my order figured out and paid for. She said the owners start baking as early as midnight for the following morning. About the only fresh donuts I've ever had. Also got a birthday cake from here and it was absolutely delicious! It's not too sweet and the decorating was perfect. They close a little early but if they are starting their day at midnight I don't blame them. You just have to plan your order.

I drove an hour away just for the amazing sugar cookies made here! Beautiful desserts, but the best part is the TASTE. Affordable, adorable desserts. Don't miss out on the sugar cookies!!!