Erika G.
Yelp
It seems kinda funny that my past couple of imbibing experiences here have been on a major calendar holiday. First Halloween for some dancing with costumed revelers and then last night for New Year's Eve. I was here with a group of friends because A) they charge no exorbitant NYE cover - in fact, it was free and B) well, that's where they wanted to go, and I am a follower, not a leader.
So there we were, hats and party favors in hand, and with my customary glass of pinot grigio (they get a star for HAVING said libation in the first place, and another for excellent bar service) I rang in 2008, in what hopes to be a continuance of the good tidings I had in the latter part of 2007. It was one of many toasts that night.
The Key Bar is great because it never feels that crowded because of its huge inside-out patio, its splendifular sidewalk people-watching and its nifty trick of giving you your credit card back to you when you open a tab, which pretty much idiot-proofs you from accidentally leaving it at the bar (guilty, party of one, my table is ready).
I should also say that I even got to witness a NYE party foul, in which some dude tripped into a heater and smashed his drink on the concrete outside. The staff was nice and prompt about cleaning up the mess. Can't speak for the humiliation of the dude, but obviously emotional counseling is not part and parcel of the bar's responsibility.
Finally, I won't give this place 5 stars because a bar has to really, really impress me to earn that vaunted decoration, and I would not go that far when describing Key Bar, but it is definitely a great place for large parties and super laid-back and accommodating for holidays/events. I should know.
So you can be sure I'll be back for President's Day, Valentine's Day and hell, maybe even Talk Like a Pirate day (Sept. 19, for anyone who is interested). They'll be sure to get the extra star if they hand out eyepatches. Arrrrr.