Key Lime To Happiness

The best Key Lime pie I've ever had! EVER!! We made a quick down-and-back trip to South Florida and wanted a Key Lime pie to share for a friend's birthday. This local shop popped up in a quick Google search and boy are we glad it did! Lauren was so sweet to help us and her pies are nothing short of amazing! We got two mini pies - the Chocolate Covered Key Lime and the Triple Key Lime. The Triple is 3 layered flavors - mango key lime, guava key lime, and traditional key lime. It was so good I ran in and bought one more for the road. We'll be returning in about 6 weeks and I may just have to order some full size pies to take home. It's that good!!!

Possibly the best key lime pie shop in WPB! They make their pies fresh each week, and it is delicious. Best hidden little secret in our area (oops, not anymore 😜) The staff is so friendly and welcoming.

Best Key Lime Pie ever. You can order a whole pie or single serve (size of a cup cake). I wish they have coffee but they only serve water. Still worthy to visit

Best key lime pie I’ve ever had. Absolutely love the thick crust. I’ve also tried the other flavors and they’re all amazing but my top two are the key lime and mango key lime. My wife loves the cheesecakes. Her top two choices are the oreo cheesecake and the funfetti cheesecake. Best advice I can give you is to simply try everything that they have and find your own favorites. You will not regret it. Placing the orders online is easy and picking up the orders is always smooth. The staff is very professional and always friendly.

If you are a key lime pie fan, this is the place. Small kind of hole in the wall place, but the pie is amazing! To me it is perfect. Not too sweet or tart, but kind of in the middle with just a hint of a tart finish. Well worth the stop if you are in the area.

Lets talk about this hidden gem! Google maps pulled up this location and I read a prior review that raved about its pies! No lies detected! The location is a bit hidden away but once you walk in you can smell the goodness. I was able to order the pie bites. The price was set to the point where i felt like i walked away with a bargain! Each pie bite was sizable and absolutely delicious. The bananas foster was my favorite by far with each bite being extremely well balanced (not overly sweet, nice bite, different textures). I took advantage while i was there and ordered the Derby Cookie. This was more of a brookie to me. Slight crunch on the outside with a chew towards the middle and layers of nuts and chocolate inside. I can see why its a favorite amongst Key Limes customers. Dont let its warehouse style location fool you, the orders were flying out the door and the owner is expecting to be super busy starting the month of October. She will be opening some availability slots soon for the month of November, so get those holiday orders in if you want to experience a slice of heaven!

Not only are the cheesecake's the BEST but so is Lauren and her family! I am obsessed with all of the wonderful flavors she creates and always so excited to try new one's. I order them for all my events and EVERYONE LOVES THEM!

I decided to try this place out because of the 5 star reviews. I won’t knock it but I didn’t enjoy any time them, even my son didn’t enjoy them. I thought it was the pie first but none of the cheesecakes were good. Literally, days later- we still hadn’t eaten them. However, the lady was nice when we picked up. The place is hard to locate but if you call, the will redirect you! Won’t return.

My fiancé prefers cheesecake over other desserts when he decides to indulge. Last year, when we lived in Virginia, i could only find a bakery that did cheesecake by the slices or a full cake. So when I found Key Lime to Happiness, i was thrilled that they were bit sized and had so many flavors to choose from. My fiancé LOVED them. Will definitely be ordering again. Highly recommend!

I came in on Pi day to get slices. After an hour of opening, half of the flavors were sold out and I was able to get some that were left. It's located in the back of an industrial area and there is limited parking since there are other businesses that are around using the parking spots too. The pie flavors I got was gluten free key lime pie (out of the regular flavor), lemon blueberry, Funfetti cheesecake, Oreo cheesecake, Butterfingers peanut butter pie, and carrot cake cheesecake. There was four of us and we had a small bite of each slice. I found the lemon blueberry and the peanut butter pie was a little rich and the other flavors were perfect. The best part was each pie slice cost the same as pi, $3.14. The staff was working hard and was very helpful behind the counter. It may be small, but the flavor is big. Go check them out if you're in the area for a piece of happiness :)

Really yummy pie, loved dealing with Lauren the baker she was so nice. the shop is very calming and minimal in design but aesthetic and smells delicious

Amazing pies, I have a lot of trouble finding good gluten free desserts but this place is phenomenal. i haven't had any flavors i didn't love and appreciate them having options for me!

The best Key Lime pie is the best in South Florida. Chocolate chip cookies also fit in the same category.

After seeing these mouthwatering cheesecakes on Instagram every week, it was time for me to give these bad boys a try and they did NOT disappoint! I bought a 6 pack and the barely lasted 5 mins between myself and my coworker. We ate them so quick I forgot to even take a photo! I asked my coworker if he likes cheesecake, he said it's his all time favorite. When he was little, his grandparents would take him to "Worlds Best Cheesecake" every time he visited them. So, I asked him if it was actually the worlds best cheesecake, and he said yes. Im happy to report that after trying the rainbow cheesecake from key lime to happiness, he has a new favorite!!! And I do too! All flavors were out of this world but the rainbow cheesecake has my heart. Can't wait to come back for more!

I can't believe it's taken me this long to write a review. I have been a customer for awhile, first discovered them when I went to the WPB greenmarket. First and foremost, Lauren and Chuck are the best. So helpful and kind and I am happy that their business is growing. I recently got to stop by to pick up treats on my birthday and had a nice time chatting The store is so cute and homey and every time I stop by they have something new to try. The guava and cream cheese cookies are amazing. Chewy and soft at the same time with a slightly crunchy top from the caramelized guava. I love all the key lime pie varieties and the peanut butter pie with peanut M&M's is sooooo good. The cherry cheesecake is also yummy. Happy to patronize small local businesses that really care about their customers!

The coconut key lime was the best key lime pie I've ever had. The owner was very friendly and helpful.

Key lime pie may seem 'easy' - pie crust, mix the filling, top with whip cream. In fact it is very easy to create a mediocre key lime pie. The hard part is getting that graham cracker crust just right. Some places seem to over-think it, trying to make the pie somehow unique for their filling, or some candied toppings etc. Thankfully, Key Line to Happiness seems to take nothing for granted. The crust, the filling, and whip cream were all perfect. Especially notable was the crust - just perfect. It was really more like they are 'honoring the key line pie' by shooting it straight, and just executing. Finding this place and setting an order for the last day of our stay was the perfect way to wrap-up the week and look forward to our next trip to south florida. Nicely done!

You will NEVER want dessert from anywhere else. I love the fact that they offer bite size so I can make my own box and not feel guilty that I didn't get all that I wanted. The lemon blueberry key lime pie and the derby pie are my two musts. FYI... they sell out fast on walk in days

The best pie I've ever had! I ordered the S'mores, S'mores with Peanuts butter and the Dirt mini pies. The first two were amazing ... they were filled with high quality chocolate that didn't taste too sweet or too oily! The Dirt wasn't really my favorite... it tasted more like a frozen chocolate mousse. The store is located in a area with a good parking access. There was a small table to enjoy your dessert in the store if you want. Also try to pre-order as they run out of their popular ones pretty quickly. You can get a mini pie for $3 or a box of 6 for $15 which is a better deal if you need more of these delicious pies.

Flavor balance! Soooo many dessert spots crank out sweets for the sake of sugariness, but not this place. The s'mores is done with dark chocolate so you can actually enjoy the marshmallows. The key lime balances sweet and tart beautifully. Palm Beach should be proud!

I've tasted alot of key lime pies in my lifetime from all over the country but this place creates an absolutely amazing key lime pie that is second to none anywhere! Graham cracker crust was delicious and the key lime filling with real whipped cream was superb. Attention to detail was obvious. Well worth the 25 minute drive to pick up. Interesting business model and marketing but to keep the price reasonable it makes perfect sense. People were very pleasant. Easy to find and to order online. Can't wait to try one of their other types of pies very soon. Thanks to Key Lime to Happiness for their creations and friendly customer appreciation.

So good and so friendly. We got a 6pk assorted mini bites. They're addictive!!! Stop by and help support a great business. Limited hours and in high demand. 100% worth it.

Oh my goodness. I've been craving Key Lime Pie. I'm also a Celiac and have difficulty finding GF Graham Cracker crust. I found Key Lime To Happiness by searching for GF Key Lime near me. My friends surprised me for my birthday with 12 mini Key Lime pies, assorted flavours. Unbelievably delicious and no ill effects! am so grateful to my friends and to Key Lime To Happiness. I'll be ordering a couple Mango Key Limes (not GF) soon for a friend's birthday.

An adorable hidden gem found by all the amazing reviews written about this place and it lives up to the hype. The place Found in the back of an industrial area, but once you find it the smell of pie wins you over. Super easy to order and I use the very user-friendly website to place an order before going. They do have some you can pick up while there but it is first come first served and it goes quick. The price Clearly listed online, no surprise fees, or upcharges. I think they seem fair. The flavor Even if you don't like pie you will find a flavor you enjoy and it might not be what you think. My husband loves dutch apple pie, but his favorite was the lemon blueberry and mine was the mango one. The sweetness isn't overpowering or very sour as you might imagine with certain flavors. It's subtle and worth the try. I recommend ordering a mini-batch of baker's choice and trying it out to find your favorite. Customer Service The website is very clear on setting expectations and you shouldn't be surprised with how to order, pick up, etc... The owners are very friendly and reply to questions very quickly.

Believe the hype. These desserts are simply awesome! Key lime pie was the best I have ever had. Can't wait to try some other flavors.

Although I had wanted to try Key Lime to Happiness for a long time, it was the beauty of all of their scrumptious-looking pies that finally got me to make an order. My 13 year old niece wants to be a food photographer, so I thought, what would be more fun than ordering a dozen assorted bites and have some quality uncle/niece time doing a photoshoot and then eating all of our props! The photos that I posted that give credit to Madison L. - those are the ones that my talented niece took - I'm so proud of her! Back to the pies - the ordering process was easy, but choosing which to include in the dozen was difficult - all of the flavors look delicious. So I chose a spread of different types of key limes, fruit pies, and chocolate-y ones as well. After putting in my order, I remembered that it was Passover, so I e-mailed the owner to see if she could postpone my order - she was so nice and accommodated my request. They were all ready when I finally picked them up, and after mentioning that my niece was interested in photography, the owner shared a food photography school opportunity with me, which was super nice. The pies are as beautiful as they were delicious. I opened up the dozen (well-packed by the way - not a one moved an inch on the way over to my sister's house), and let me tell you, having to ward off three adults and four kids circling around these treats was a difficult job. As soon as we had our fun and took all of the photos we could, we carefully split each one and shared the dozen. They didn't last half an hour, and as eyes rolled back into our heads, plates were being licked clean. I highly recommend getting the dozen to start off with, because you'll find all of the textures - from velvety to chunky to gooey to crumbly, and so many flavor combos. The tropical fruit cheesecakes were sweet and sour and tasted like real fruit. The s'mores pie was every kid's campfire dream (without the campfire). I had such a good time, and know that next time when I pick up my next order, my expectations are once again going to be blown away.

The first time we ordered from here, the place decor was welcoming, as was the staff. She is friendly and helpful. The most important part is that the pies are delicious. We will definitely come back and order more. What a hidden gem we found in the WPB area!

If I could give 10 stars, I would. This small business is female owned and operated and everything is delicious. Lauren offers both gluten free and gluten-filled specialty pies and pie bites that are out of this world. The gluten free is made in a separate area and, as someone with celiac, I have never had an issue before. This is a great stop if you're in the area or have a party/gathering/special occasion, or if you're just looking for a wonderful dessert for everyday. She also does seasonal flavors that you do NOT want to miss.

I have been ordering her pies now for two years, and they never disappoint! My entire family loves them and we order them for special occasions. My favorites would be the quava cheesecake and the yo dabba do!

This place is a total gem to find. The pies are all good but my favorite is the s'mores peanut butter with the chocolate. The owner is super friendly and will chat with you to help you find a flavor that's right for you

These are the most delicious treats. I picked up a box for Father's Day lunch. They were a huge hit! Everyone loved and raved about them. They are very reasonably priced and pick up options were super convenient. It's right down the street from my job so I look forward to stopping by again.

These little pies bring happiness with every bite! I've been wanting to try this place for awhile now and I'm upset how long it took me to get here. I love that you can customize your order and try different flavors. Not all pies are key lime they have a variety of cheesecake based flavors, fudge/chocolate and key lime spin offs. My absolute favorites were the Oreo cheesecake, key lime, and guava cheesecake. You have to pre-order in order to guarantee the flavors you want. They also offer store walk-ins but your options are limited. They make everything fresh to order which is noticeable in the quality of the pies. The store is located in an odd location but it's surprisingly cute inside.

I ordered the gluten free key lime pie and it did not disappoint!! Amazingly creamy filling with a tasty crust. It was the perfect blend of tart and sweet. The process to order and pick up was super easy too. The shop itself is adorable and very clean. As a person with Celiac Disease, I knew I was taking a chance because they don't have separate "gluten free" kitchen, but it was my chance to take. I'm happy to report that this pie was indeed gluten free and was not cross contaminated in any way. Big thank you for the amazing pie. I'll be back!!

Wow.. that's pretty much the only think that comes to mind because these pies left me speechless. We drove about 40 minutes to come try at around noon(roughly 2 hours before close). Called before hand to see if we could reserve an order. We had high hopes when the nice lady told us they were almost sold out. Also, they were extremely nice people. She even called me back to let me know exactly what pies they had left after someone ordered a dozen. Very nice and accommodating. We were lucky enough to try 6 pies that we had picked out prior! How lucky is that?? Like it was meant to be. And it definitely was. When we walked in, we were immediately greeted by two nice people and got to see an awesome walk-in refrigerator. It was very cool. She informed me that the lady before us had just officially sold them out so I was lucky enough to get an order before hand. I'd say just based on appearances the value is amazing. After getting in the car we could not wait to try. I took my first bite of the key lime and it was incredible. Some of the best I've had. It was very evident that the pie filling was made with really fresh ingredients. Everything was perfectly sweet and tart and delicious. Just based on that I would go back A LOT. Then we got on to the strawberry key lime(amazing). Banana foster cheesecake(this was for my gf as I don't care for banana but it was still delicious), The carrot cake, and the Oreo peanut butter(WOW)! Honestly everything was so delicious I can't wait to go back. It is a must try. I would recommend preorder as they only have walk ins on certain days. Thanks!

Umm ya, this place is absolutely amazing! I won't even get into how amazing every one that i got is. They are all top of the line best pies I've ever had! The woman working was super friendly and nice. Just go, order and pick up on a Friday so you can get some of the walk in menu items!! Just go and trust me, I've never fed you wrong!!

I ordered 2 dozen assorted pie bites for a birthday party and they were a total hit! These pies are so delicious! There are so many flavors to choose from and every single one is amazing! I'm so glad I discovered Key Lime to Happiness!!

The mini pies/cheesecake bites are delicious, have enjoyed every flavor we've tried...but the MUST get is her key lime pie. Hands down the best key lime pie. No longer have to drive to Mrs. Mac's in Key Largo (iykyk) it's THAT good.

I hate cheesecake but this made me change my mind. The combination of cake and cheesecake are scrumptious. My favorite was the banana bread fingertip cheesecake and for St. Pattys the red velvet in green.

My employer bought a pie for each employee and I received a cinnamon apple cheesecake. It was one of the best pies I've ever eaten. All of my colleagues had similar experiences and we each had a different pie. When I went to pick up our order (over 20 pies) the owners were incredibly appreciative for the business and helped load the pies into the car. I encourage everyone to give them a try.

Amazing! Perfect sizes and absolutely delicious. We ordered a dozen and loved every single flavor available. The owners were so friendly and very helpful in our selection. My family will be ordering from here again.

Key Lime to Happiness is, by far, our favorite dessert spot in South Florida. Everything we've tried (most of the menu) is absolutely delicious. Any time we have guests in town we're sure to take or send them here. On top of an amazing product, the owner and her family are an absolute joy. This place is amazing!

This place is an absolute gem. Everything on the menu is a winner. They offer a wide variety of different options and the pie bites are a great way to try many of their amazing flavors. Their stuff is so good that we've become weekly regulars! I cannot recommend Key Lime to Happiness enough.

I ordered an assortment to take to a work party, everyone loved them and I don't think I'll ever bother baking myself again. I really appreciated that they took the time to label the flavors.

Best pies around. Key Lime was fabulous. I've enjoyed her fruit pies in the past. Cheesecake is excellent also. Worth the trip to Pick up.

We ordered over 20 pies for Thanksgiving for our associates. They were a hit! I can't believe how many people called today to say that their pie was the best pie they've every tasted. We were happy that everyone enjoyed their pies and we look forward to our next order. Lauren was so easy to work with and she even accommodated us when we ask for 3 extra pies! This is the place to get your pies. Delicious.

First tried the key lime with the chocolate cover. Best key lime pie I've ever had (and I've had a lot). Next had the strawberry key lime again with the chocolate and whipped cream (Like a chocolate covered strawberry). Best dessert I've ever had. Not much more I can (or need to) say, except that you. Must. Try. This. Pie.

So good but make sure look at their website for hours. It's in a random small building, look for entrance.pies are great! Small local business to support!! I'm going to preorder when I have family and friends in town.

Absolutely phenomenal! My boss bought holiday pies for each of us prior to Thanksgiving. I got the pecan (one of my favorites!)...but this one BY FAR was the best I've ever had. I will be ordering again, and can't wait to buy pies as gifts for friends and family for each holiday! DEFINITELY CHECK THEM OUT! Amazing!