Brian A.
Yelp
Quite honestly, the food is good, and service is okay, but to lift this place above so many others (even within a stones throw distance) is going way too far.
We have this problem a lot in LA - restaurants get some recognition, and then they start getting busy and hard to get into. In trust, what actually happens is some arbitrary event that shines a spotlight on the restaurant (like a celebrity dining there). The next thing you know is everybody's going there and leaving raving reviews, not because the food or service was great, but because they want to be seen as "in the know". Frankly, most of the time (in LA at least) the restaurant is not really that good, but everybody is afraid to say anything to the contrary.
La Pepita is not bad, don't get me wrong. It gets three stars because it's right there among the average restaurant in the area.
There is one thang that absolutely upset me, although I promise it did not affect my rating: Shortly after we were sat (in the corner, next to the wine closet), the 4-top next to us left, and the restaurant sat 7 large adults at a 4 top table. because the opposite side from us was the only door, all 7 people had to cram on our side of the table. I was pushed into the corner, to the point that I could no longer freely move arms to eat. I had a large man, sitting on a backless stool, with his back leaning up against my 2 foot wide table. I know people say this place is cozy, but that was the most uncomfortable situation I have ever been forced to endure at a restaurant.
It is because of this that I will never return, but the food was good. Still, there is so much better.